This week we look back to February 2004 and a more Datsyukian time  

I find that I focus a lot of my fantasy hockey prognosticating on younger players. It seems to be one of the more enjoyable aspects of being a poolie. Hunting the “next big thing”, trying to weed through line combinations and scouting reports to understand just how good Ryan Johansen is, or whether or not Kucherov will last long term for Tampa.

With all this time spent on the future, I sometimes overlook the importance of reviewing current stars. I’ll expect players like Thornton, Datsyuk, Iginla, or Marleau to produce at their usual clip, ending with decent point totals and strong peripherals. Of course at some point the music has to stop for even the most consistent of producers – as my friend likes to remind me – father time remains undefeated with a record of (insert any number) to 0. The guy must have a mean right hook, or be a southpaw, or something.

The decline of existing fantasy stars is a tough thing to monitor. In some cases a player can legitimately have a down season (new line mates, new system, nagging injury, poor shooting percentage, bad luck…etc) in other cases poor production can signal diminishing physical skills – which is when we start to worry. Of course deciding between the two is difficult. Raise your hand if you thought Teemu Selanne was close to done after 2004 with 32 points in 78 games for Colorado? (I was convinced his days as an elite option were likely over).

This all brings me to the interesting case of Pavel Datsyuk. In addition to being an absolute joy to watch (is there a better pair of hands in sport?) he has also established himself as one the most consistent fantasy options over the past decade. His most impressive run came between 2006 and 2009 when he finished with point totals of 87, 87, 97, 97 and never shot less than 200 times. Since that time he’s regularly considered among the top 10-15 forward options on many draft boards.

The question is, should he be today? Or is this a case of some residual value carrying over for a star player?

To get an idea of just how long Datsyuk has been at the forefront of the hockey world I wanted to look back to Dobber’s rankings in February of 2004 (image below). At this time the wings center was just breaking into the NHL, but had already established himself as the 15th most valuable skater.



Rank Team PLAYER
1 VAN Naslund, Markus
2 BOS Thornton, Joe
3 ATL Kovalchuk, Ilya
4 OTT Hossa, Marian
5 VAN Bertuzzi, Todd
6 NYR Jagr, Jaromir
7 COL Forsberg, Peter
8 COL Tanguay, Alex
9 COL Hejduk, Milan
10 STL Demitra, Pavol
11 TOR Sundin, Mats
12 PHO Nagy, Ladislav
13 OTT Alfredsson, Daniel
14 COL Sakic, Joe
15 DET Datsyuk, Pavel
16 VAN Morrison, Brendan
17 TB Lecavalier, Vincent
18 STL Tkachuk, Keith
19 CGY Iginla, Jarome
20 WAS Lang, Robert
21 OTT Spezza, Jason
22 TB St. Louis, Martin
23 PHO Doan, Shane
24 NYR Kovalev, Alex
25 STL Weight, Doug
26 ATL Savard, Marc
27 SJ Marleau, Patrick
28 DAL Modano, Michael
29 ANA Fedorov, Sergei
30 DET Shanahan, Brendan
31 TB Richards, Brad
32 BUF Satan, Miroslav
33 BOS Murray, Glen
34 NJ Elias, Patrik
35 BUF Briere, Daniel
36 PHI Roenick, Jeremy
37 DAL Guerin, Bill
38 COL Kariya, Paul
39 DET Hull, Brett
40 COL Selanne, Teemu
41 PHI Gagne, Simon
42 MIN Gaborik, Marian
43 CBJ Nash, Rick
44 OTT Havlat, Martin
45 BUF Drury, Chris
46 ATL Heatley, Dany
47 TB Stillman, Cory
48 EDM Hemsky, Ales
49 ATL Kozlov, Vyacheslav
50 OTT Bonk, Radek



Beginning in 2010 Datsyuk’s numbers took a bit of a hit, dropping to only 70 points and 203 shots in 80 games. At this juncture it was difficult to tell if he simply went through a difficult year (he had posted 97 points in the previous season) or if something deeper was occurring. Since then he has dealt with a couple of injures, while the production has remained very good, but maybe not elite.

Last year Datsyuk reminded us that he still was capable of top 20 production with 49 points and a plus 21 rating in only 47 games. Now, at the age of 35, he’s again dealing with injuries and the production (33 in 37 games, with a minus 4 rating) isn’t quite where it once was. The question becomes, how do we value him moving forward?

I don’t know if there is a definitive answer, as the truth likely lies somewhere in the middle. Datsyuk has certainly retained significant value (unlike his cohorts Heatley and Lecavalier) but doesn’t appear to be as reliable has be was four or five seasons ago.

When valuing existing stars I always like to take a moment and try to separate the name and my admiration for a specific player from their actual statistics. In this case we have to be cognizant that Datysuk received a lot of attention over the past 10 years, and he may not be able to provide the uber elite production that likely follows his name in fantasy circles.

I’d love to hear what you think his numbers could be over the next two or three years, find me on twitter @FantasyHockeyDK

Also check out -

Looking July, 2010 Top Prospects 
Looking February, 2003 Top Players 


You need to login to post comments. Registration takes 5 seconds. See link at top left under "home"