EDIT: Decision has been made.

I'd drop Bieksa and Shattenkirk and grab both Zidlicky and McCabe.

McCabe > Bieksa
Zidlicky > Shattenkirk

Bieksa's peripherals aren't that good and he gets limited PP-time in Vancouver even with all their injuries in the back end. Shattenkirk like the Avs are slumping and they're facing a lot of injuries and Forsberg didn't provide much on a boost for them so look for them to continue their slide.

McCabe and Zidlicky should both have better production all-around for the rest of the season than Bieksa and Shattenkirk.

Thanks Carcillo. I was curious about Bieksa's peripherals (non-offensive ones) and just compared to both McCabe and Zidlicky, and it's not that much in Bieksa's favour as I would have thought, specifically hits and blocks. He gets more PIM but that's not enough of a reason to keep him.

Exactly. Both Zidlicky and McCabe are actually surprisingly good in hits and blocked shots.

Moves have been made. Thanks again.