who wins this?

__________________
Keeper League
Keep 16, Dress 12 Skaters,6D,3Goalies Bench 6
6 Skater Cats G,A,Pts,PPG,+/-,PIM
3 Goalie Cats SPG,GAA,GPS
Forwards: Perry DSedin Spezza MKoivu Skinner Seguin
Defence: Doughty Karlsson Myers Boyle Subban Kaberle
Goalies: Lundqvist Price

in my kind of pool.....there is no way you can win if you are trading CROSBY.

In a one year pool I can imagine that it\'s easy to trade for 3 greats studs.....maybe

and without more info on your pool it\'s hard to qualify this trade....

__________________
Keeper League( 10 gm), 1 goalie + 1 team, pt only

PURCELL, CONACHER, , EBERLE, GIROUX, SUTER, BENN, OSHIE, TAVARES, J.STAAL, BERGERON, WHEELER, DUPUIS, MUELLER,ELIAS, BERGLUND, BRUNNER,STREIT,CALLAHAN

PHILLY
LUNDQVIST

BENCH:
RHN,PAAJARVI,KUZNETSOV,J.SCHULTZ, C.ATKINSON,VOKOUN(G)

Lifetime Keeper. Keep 16. Thornton and Datsyuk for Crosby. Points are standard. G/A/+/-/Pts/STG/PIM.

__________________
Keeper League
Keep 16, Dress 12 Skaters,6D,3Goalies Bench 6
6 Skater Cats G,A,Pts,PPG,+/-,PIM
3 Goalie Cats SPG,GAA,GPS
Forwards: Perry DSedin Spezza MKoivu Skinner Seguin
Defence: Doughty Karlsson Myers Boyle Subban Kaberle
Goalies: Lundqvist Price

I know everyone has the rule, never trade crosby, but Id make the trade if you are weak at your center position after crosby, if your not there is no point in making the trade.
Crosby is sick but just cause he\'s on your team doesn\'t mean your goign to win each year, just look at your center depth and go from there.

well, given your team it looks like you would be recieving crosby. Here is the deal with him. In a life time keeper always make the trade for crosby, sure you might need to \"rebuild\" for a season or two, but once you get him, hes your \"keeper\" for his whole career. ... aka about 19 straight 100+ pt seasons with lots of HUGE totals thrown in. Pull the trigger, you win hands down.