not sure whats going on with carle so im kind of tempted to accept. I picked up ozlinsch already.

__________________

Carle is off to a very slow start. But... Neidermyer isn\'t actually playing yet. I would try for someone else, because although Neidermyer is a stud, he\'s not in game shape, and time has shown its takes a player who has missed camp time to adjust. So, even if Niedermyer gets in for 40 games and gets 30 points, there are loads of 30 point defensemen out there. And with no guarentee of him actually playing, I wouldn\'t bother with this.

__________________
10 Team Keeper, Points Only, 9 active fwds, 4 active def, 5 reserves with weekly subs

Springfield Isotopes - Returning to power in 2010-2011
Fwds: Backstrom, E. Staal, Toews, Ryan, Duchenne, Fleishchman (?), Weiss (TBD), Heatley (TBD), Oshie (?), Frolik (TBD), O'Sullivan(TBD), Hemsky, Pacioretty (TBD), Filatov, Turris
Def: Yandle, E. Johnson, Goligoski (need 2 more min)

TBD - To be dropped (for various reasons)
? - option to drop

there are lots of 30 points in 80 game D out there...very few who will get 30 points in 40 games. Nieds still has value at the end of the season to replace an average D.

repenttokyo wrote:
Exactly.

I wouldn\'t do the trade unless you can convince him to give you something better than Carle. Nieds will power your second half if he comes back. Of course you risk losing him for nothing if he decides he\'s not coming back, so if you really want to deal him, look for something better.

thanks for your responses... not too sure i can get anything more than neidermayer since carle has been a healthy scratch for 3 games now and pretty much everyone in my league is aware of that

__________________

mm12 wrote:
Oh wait...you get Nieds, sorry I totally misunderstood.

I would do the deal...bit of a risk, but I\'d do it.