13 team, points only.

16 forwards, 4 dmen, 2 teams (win = 1 pt, sho = 3 pts)

1st year of a 2 year semi-keeper (we keep 4 fwds and 2 dmen/teams for next year)

this is a deal that i proposed to a guy that\'s been clamouring for my justin williams. he\'s been really difficult to deal with and i\'m not a fan of a lot of his forwards.

now i should start by saying that i\'m not even sure i would take this deal. i figure for this season that pronger would make up the points that williams will outscore perry by. he\'s also suggested potentially switching out pronger for campbell, which i\'m against, but is the downgrade that much?

my major concern is whether or not perry would be considered keeper material for next year, his 4th, and typically a breakout year.

my team looks like this right now:

thornton
cheechoo
kovalchuk
juwill
havlat
bouchard
prospal
t ruutu
kotalik
lombardi
stafford
malone
bell
madden
vrbata
campoli
boyle
bouwmeester
bergeron
murphy
nashville
florida

another thing to consider is that the addition of either pronger or campbell gives me some really solid dmen that i could potentially parlay into a forward upgrade. we also have a limit of 30 moves throughout the 2 years and i believe i\'m at 6 right now.

sorry for the length, but more perspectives would be great!

__________________
11 team roto league keep 17/25
G,A,P,PPP,PIM,SHP,SOG,FW,W,GAA,SV%,SHO

c-stastny,gomez,o'reilly,gaustad
lw-kovalchuk,heatley,mcdonald(c),o'sullivan,tkachuk,t .ruutu
rw-alfredsson,dumont,ju.williams,mueller(c),langenbru nner
d-boyle,streit,zidlicky,enstrom,yandle,carkner
g-fleury,hiller,c.mason,schneider
ir-savard,bouchard,letang
farm-tavares,turris,colborne,MSP,pacioretty,markstrom

I would keep your side....Williams is a good yound player and Bergeron will be a great fantasy defenseman. I guess it depends on if you are gonna keep mab. But if I were you Williams and Bergeron side wins. Pronger getting up there in years. See what else you can get out of him if he wants williams that bad.

__________________
Keepers right now are in CAPS

C- TAVARES, H.SEDIN, M. Koivu, Henrique
LW- BENN, PARISE, Brown, Pacrioretty
RW- GIROUX, KESSEL, Nash, Read
D- YANDLE, KARLSSON, Wisniewski, Gologoski
G- LUNDQVIST, Luongo, Schneider, Halak
Bench- Ruutu, Quincey, Ribeiro

8 Team Keeper League Keep 2C 2LW 2RW 2D 1 G
G(+10) A(+5) +/-(1) GWG(+5) W(+15) L(-5) SO(+20) (+.5)PIM

i wouldn\'t be keeping mab out of those dmen, that\'s for sure, especially since last year he was nolan\'s darling and this year i think he slept with nolan\'s wife and if i can move him i will, but i don\'t want to take a huge hit with my forwards and need some help with my keepers.

he\'s adamant he\'s not giving me pronger and keeps saying that some say mab is hurt, which is news to me, but whatever.

here\'s his roster, if it helps:

heatley
stastny
gabby
langkow
brindy
nagy
connolly
perry
tucker
hecht
higgins
svatos
reinprecht
jawilliams
federov
fedotenko
pronger
campbell
blake
ranger
buffalo
toronto

he refuses to move healtley and stastny (even if i overpay!) and for the record, on my current roster, i\'d be keeping joey t, cheechoo (yikes), kovalchuk, and juwill and probably boyle and bouwmeester for next year, IF bouwmeester picks it up.

__________________
11 team roto league keep 17/25
G,A,P,PPP,PIM,SHP,SOG,FW,W,GAA,SV%,SHO

c-stastny,gomez,o'reilly,gaustad
lw-kovalchuk,heatley,mcdonald(c),o'sullivan,tkachuk,t .ruutu
rw-alfredsson,dumont,ju.williams,mueller(c),langenbru nner
d-boyle,streit,zidlicky,enstrom,yandle,carkner
g-fleury,hiller,c.mason,schneider
ir-savard,bouchard,letang
farm-tavares,turris,colborne,MSP,pacioretty,markstrom