Which side would you rather be on?

Points are:
G (25), A (25), +/- (10), PIM (3), PPG (10), PPA (5), SHG (15), SHA (5), GWG (15), SOG (2), FW (1), FL (-1)

The other guy really wants Lidstrom, is this too fair or should I try for more off him?

__________________
(G) (A) 25, (+/-) 5, (PIM) 3, (PPG) 7.5, (PPA) 5, (SHG) 10, (SHA) 7.5
(SOG) 1
(W) 50, (L) -20, (GA) -5, (SV) 2, (SHO) 50

You should definately do it because you also carry Rafalski on your team. I know Lidstrom is better, but you would also not be putting all your eggs in one basket. I think Paul Stasny is gonna have a great season. He tends to be streaky, but I see a 90pt. year for him. I dont think pominville will pass the 70pt. mark. Lidstrom may get more points for you than gonchar, if assists is what you aim for, but I think gonchar is a guaranteed top defensemen, who will not only diversify your team a little, but he will also be an asset to the power play. This trade is a steal for you, so I would definately take it before he rethinks it.

__________________

16 Team Full Keeper - Yahoo H2H League (No Playoffs)
Positions:12F,6D,2G,5BN,4IR
Forwards/Defensemen:G,A,P,+/-,PIM,PPP,SHP,GWG,SOG
Goalies:W,GAA,SV%,SHO
[F]- A.Ovechkin, N.Backstrom, D.Sedin, H.Sedin, T.Hall, J.Iginla, G.Landeskog, J.Huberdeau, M.Havlat, J.Franzen, B.Gionta, M.Granlund, A.Tanguay, M.Paajarvi, J.Jagr, M.Calvert
[D]- K.Yandle, D.Boyle, D.Phaneuf, M.Zidlicky, D.Wideman, A.Larsson
[G]- J.Howard, C.Anderson, B.Elliott