Which set of these keepers would you rather, and why?

I'm working some deals to impact keepers, which scenario should I target?


# 1:

C - Backstrom
LW - Kovy
LW - Ovy
LW - Heatley
RW - Perry


#2:
C - Malkin
C- Backstrom
LW - Kovy
LW - Ovy
Rw - Kane


#3:
C - Malkin
LW - Kovy
Lw - Ovy
LW- Heatley
RW - Kane


Discuss

__________________
12 Team H2H Yahoo Keeper (Year 6)
Champion 2008-09, 2009-10 & 2010-11, Runner-up 2010-11
Keep 5 (4 Skaters, 1 Goalie)

G | A | PTS | PPP | +/- | SOG | HIT | W | SV | SV% | GAA | SO

C - Stamkos, Malkin,
LW - Ovechkin
RW - Perry
D -
Util -
G - Lundqvist

#3 and stop bragging, lol.

__________________
10 Team Dynasty League ($89.4 cap), 2009-2010 Champion (RS and PO)
C: Crosby, Getzlaf, Carter, Ott, Hanzal
R: Semin, Pavelski, Langenbrunner, Little, Benn
L: D. Sedin, Eriksson, Laich, Burrows, Tanguay, Macarther
D: Green, Weber, Burns, Ehrhoff, Enstrom, Robidas, Foster
G: Rinne, Howard

IR: Oshie, Stafford, Miller

Minors: McCollum, Lindberg, McBain, Franson, Niskanen, Hodgson, Grabner, Schroeder, Tedenby, Colborne, Kreider, Tatar, R. O'Reilly, Skille, Radulov etc, etc

haha thanks, in #3, if Kane was replaced by Perry would you still take #3?

__________________
12 Team H2H Yahoo Keeper (Year 6)
Champion 2008-09, 2009-10 & 2010-11, Runner-up 2010-11
Keep 5 (4 Skaters, 1 Goalie)

G | A | PTS | PPP | +/- | SOG | HIT | W | SV | SV% | GAA | SO

C - Stamkos, Malkin,
LW - Ovechkin
RW - Perry
D -
Util -
G - Lundqvist

C - Malkin
LW - Kovy
Lw - Ovy
LW- Heatley
RW - Kane

Yes, and it's not even close, Trahey!

There is one centre better than Malkin to have in a keeper core. Boohoo, you don't have Crosby.

There are no LWs better than Ovy.

There is one LW better than Heatley. There is also on LW better than Kovalchuk. The player in question for both these cases is Ovechkin (Heater and Kovy are tied).

Kane is a top-3 RW. The distance between Kane and Perry is NOTHING compared to having Malkin at C and that trio of megastuds at LW.

Ridiculous.

__________________

Thanks fella's

Too bad we cut the keepers to 5 this year as opposed to the entire team, it took me 3 years to build a superteam

__________________
12 Team H2H Yahoo Keeper (Year 6)
Champion 2008-09, 2009-10 & 2010-11, Runner-up 2010-11
Keep 5 (4 Skaters, 1 Goalie)

G | A | PTS | PPP | +/- | SOG | HIT | W | SV | SV% | GAA | SO

C - Stamkos, Malkin,
LW - Ovechkin
RW - Perry
D -
Util -
G - Lundqvist

It's not even a big deal, Trahey... nobody else in your league will have as much talent as you consolidated into as few spots. You will have a major advantage year-in and year-out because of that! Enjoy the ride...

__________________

thanks man haha, unfourtunately I'm not eligible to win the prize (we put up 3 jerseys a year) but I took over the commish position from my friend (its a friends league) since his gf had a baby, now i gotta be commish lol

however, the yahoo trophy and bragging rights is good enough for me haha

thanks guys

__________________
12 Team H2H Yahoo Keeper (Year 6)
Champion 2008-09, 2009-10 & 2010-11, Runner-up 2010-11
Keep 5 (4 Skaters, 1 Goalie)

G | A | PTS | PPP | +/- | SOG | HIT | W | SV | SV% | GAA | SO

C - Stamkos, Malkin,
LW - Ovechkin
RW - Perry
D -
Util -
G - Lundqvist