League in signature, got sent this offer for JT. We only keep 3 and I was wanting to keep him but this offer helps me contend for a title this year as Staal should outpoint JT, and Goli should get about 15-20 more than jackman the rest of the season.

My only concern is I dont think I will keep Staal (team in sig).

Let me know what you would do with this offer.

__________________
19 Team Keeper -Staight points - +2W,-1L, +4SO

9 Forwards (Vinny, Oli, Stasny, JT, Berlund, Giroux, Sullivan, Kostysyn, Conolly)
6 Defence (Webber, E.Johnson,J.Johnson,Gilbert, Bogosian, Jackman)
2 Goalies (Luongo, Quick)
Keep 3

Fair offer. I even kinda prefer your side of it.

Just curious, why wouldn't you keep Staal? IMO, he would be your no. 2 keeper behind luongo.

__________________
13 team Keeper, top 8F, 4D and 2G count. 1pt G/A, 2pt W/SO.
Protect b/w 375 - 400 points in a full season

F: Spezza, P Kane, E Staal, B Richards, RNH, E Kane, Weiss, Jagr, Briere, Semin, Hemsky

D: Suter, Giordano, Ryan Whitney, Goligoski, Souray, Spurgeon

G: Rask, Pavelec, Theodore, Elliott

I guess I could keep Stall, I view Vinny as having more upside, and Stasny as a similar player. Might try and get Datysuk for JT instead tho!

__________________
19 Team Keeper -Staight points - +2W,-1L, +4SO

9 Forwards (Vinny, Oli, Stasny, JT, Berlund, Giroux, Sullivan, Kostysyn, Conolly)
6 Defence (Webber, E.Johnson,J.Johnson,Gilbert, Bogosian, Jackman)
2 Goalies (Luongo, Quick)
Keep 3

Seriously. Who are you keeping over Staal?

Never mind -- didn't ask quick enough.

__________________
Points-only, Full Keeper Dynasty League
Active roster (no starts, just total points): 12 FW, 6 D, 1 Goalie

Forwards: Ovechkin, D. Sedin, Stastny, Nash, Kesler, Ribeiro, B. Richards, Selanne, Hossa, Fleischmann, Whitney, Lecavalier, Alfredsson, Okposo, Plekanec, Doan, S. Kostitsyn

Defense: Goligoski, Campbell, Gonchar, Bergeron, Liles, McBain, Vatanen, Timonen, Visnovsky, Giordano, Wideman

Goal: Luongo, Holtby

Yeah I'd say pull the trigger on that one if you a serious about contending for the title this year. Worst case scenario you're stuck with a player (staal) whos consistently produces at point per game pace, rarely misses time and logs serious minutes (much on the PP)

So I just swong 2 deals....... First. I get Thornton,Sharpe,Boyes, Lunqvist, a 8th and 9th rounder for Vinny, O.Jokinen, Brule, Quick, a 1st and a 4th...Which now makes my keepers Luongo, Lunqvist, Thornton so I did this deal next, E.Staal and Goli for my JT and Jackman....


Thoughts, now thats its all done?

__________________
19 Team Keeper -Staight points - +2W,-1L, +4SO

9 Forwards (Vinny, Oli, Stasny, JT, Berlund, Giroux, Sullivan, Kostysyn, Conolly)
6 Defence (Webber, E.Johnson,J.Johnson,Gilbert, Bogosian, Jackman)
2 Goalies (Luongo, Quick)
Keep 3

you did great

Thanks....Would anyone not have Luongo, Lunqvist, and Thornton pegged as there 3 keepers if they were me?

Note- Im low on early picks, so I think carrying 2 goalies is even more critical.

__________________
19 Team Keeper -Staight points - +2W,-1L, +4SO

9 Forwards (Vinny, Oli, Stasny, JT, Berlund, Giroux, Sullivan, Kostysyn, Conolly)
6 Defence (Webber, E.Johnson,J.Johnson,Gilbert, Bogosian, Jackman)
2 Goalies (Luongo, Quick)
Keep 3

With 19 teams and 6 D, the talent pool in that area seems very thin, yet you currently have a very solid set. Is there a D in there that you would consider over Lunqvist?

Just something to think about. With 19 teams and 2G, having Luongo and Lunqvist is a great things as well = )

__________________
12 Team Keeper league point only (Rebuild mode)
F - Tavares, Kovalchuck, M.Richards, Horton, Ju.Williams, Roy, Tanguay, Gerbe
D - Weber, Goligoski, Souray, Salo,
G - Rask, Crawford
Farm - Elliot, Read, Hodgson, Kuznetsov, Huberdeau, Granlund, Zibanejad, Burmistrov, Ennis, McBain, Schwartz

Well I got Webber and EJohnson on D but I think D men (minus Mike Green) are easier to find. Lots of teams have fixed D issues after the draft but few have been able to get much goalie help at a fair price.

__________________
19 Team Keeper -Staight points - +2W,-1L, +4SO

9 Forwards (Vinny, Oli, Stasny, JT, Berlund, Giroux, Sullivan, Kostysyn, Conolly)
6 Defence (Webber, E.Johnson,J.Johnson,Gilbert, Bogosian, Jackman)
2 Goalies (Luongo, Quick)
Keep 3