who would you rather take in a yahoo keeper league: Shea Weber or Matt Carle? this is the scoring system: (G,A,P,+/-,PIMS,PPP,SHP,GWG,Shots)

who has more offensive upside? Weber seems like he could give a few more PIMs than Carle, but I don\'t know if one has a lot more offensive upside than the other considering Carle could play PP with Thornton.

I have debated that one myself for a long time and still don\'t really have an answer. If you count +/- in your league I would probably go with Weber as he is more of a rock in his own end. Carle will probably get more points but Weber will get similar PPP because of his rocket shot, as well as more PIM\'s.


Really tough call, because I really like both of them, but it\'s probably Weber for me.

Can you give me a comment on my team?

http://www.dobberhockey.com/componen...28580/catid,5/

__________________
15 GM CBS Roto Keeper League (4th year)
G-A-STP-PIM-W-GAA
Start: 3C/2LW/2RW/2F/4D/3G
Keep 24

C: Kopitar, Carter, M. Koivu, Weiss, Anisimov, Tatar
L: Zetterberg, Vanek, Ott, Steen, Tedenby
R: Hemsky, Giroux, Selanne, Fehr, Zuccarello-Aasen
D: Chara, E. Johnson, Rafalski, Bieksa, Barker, B. Smith
G: Lundqvist, Rask, Howard, Dekanich