Need to protect 10 (players/team/goaler) or if you prefer I need to unprotect 5 ....

need advice!

Brodeur M
Detroit
Sakic J
Savard M
Briere D
Selanne T
Alfredss D
Whitney R
Kariya P
Recchi M
Pominvil J
Dumont J
Shanahan B
Arnott J
Boyes B

__________________
Keeper League( 10 gm), 1 goalie + 1 team, pt only

PURCELL, CONACHER, , EBERLE, GIROUX, SUTER, BENN, OSHIE, TAVARES, J.STAAL, BERGERON, WHEELER, DUPUIS, MUELLER,ELIAS, BERGLUND, BRUNNER,STREIT,CALLAHAN

PHILLY
LUNDQVIST

BENCH:
RHN,PAAJARVI,KUZNETSOV,J.SCHULTZ, C.ATKINSON,VOKOUN(G)

superluke wrote:
Does your league have postional requirements? Are goals worth more?
Need more info before making any suggestions

it doesn\'t matter what the league rules are... i believe there are a couple of obvious players you should dump:

superluke wrote:
lose these 5 players. the only other borderline players are shanahan and selanne (he might retire this year). when keeping guys like brodeur, sakic, and alfredsson, you\'re more interested in winning now rather than later. thus, i\'d keep selanne and shanahan (both guys can score 40g) over a younger pominville (who will do worse without briere) and arnott (top center on a decent nashville offense)

5 to unprotect, I think would be :

Whitney R
Recchi M
Pominvil J
Dumont J
Arnott J

Tough call. Go with Dobber\'s ranking!
1) I\'m assuming it\'s Ray Whitney. If it\'s Ryan, keep him. Ray can be injured easily and last year was a lucky healthy season.
2) If you can wait for Selanne\'s situation, you might unprotect him.

__________________
QHL Stanley Cup champion 2006-07, 2007-08, 2008-09
www.thephysicsofhockey.com

I would release Arnott, Pommer, Recchi, Dumont and Wolski.

__________________
My keeper squad on this 10 team, no positional requirement league (except 1 goalie and 1 NHL team). Points only: Parise, Kopitar, Hemsky, Brunette, J Staal, Okposo, Doan, Roy, O.Jokinen, Giroux, Krejci, Oshie, Eberle, Little, Filpulla, Steen, Filatov, Hudler, H.Lundqvist, + NHL Team LA.

Why did I put Wolski on that list? Brain fart I guess... Obviously, drop Selanne if he retires or Williams if no retirement is planned for Selanne.

__________________
My keeper squad on this 10 team, no positional requirement league (except 1 goalie and 1 NHL team). Points only: Parise, Kopitar, Hemsky, Brunette, J Staal, Okposo, Doan, Roy, O.Jokinen, Giroux, Krejci, Oshie, Eberle, Little, Filpulla, Steen, Filatov, Hudler, H.Lundqvist, + NHL Team LA.

Another brain fart ?!

After Wolski, it\'s Williams ?

__________________
QHL Stanley Cup champion 2006-07, 2007-08, 2008-09
www.thephysicsofhockey.com

nothing surprising me with stephane richer!

He always had some brain fart!

BTW stephane Richer is and others owners from our league!

also 1 pt for normal keeper league, no positional required except goalie and a team

Post edited by: superluke, at: 2007/07/10 11:30

Post edited by: superluke, at: 2007/07/10 11:41

__________________
Keeper League( 10 gm), 1 goalie + 1 team, pt only

PURCELL, CONACHER, , EBERLE, GIROUX, SUTER, BENN, OSHIE, TAVARES, J.STAAL, BERGERON, WHEELER, DUPUIS, MUELLER,ELIAS, BERGLUND, BRUNNER,STREIT,CALLAHAN

PHILLY
LUNDQVIST

BENCH:
RHN,PAAJARVI,KUZNETSOV,J.SCHULTZ, C.ATKINSON,VOKOUN(G)

Drop :

Selanne
Whitney
Recchi
Dumont
Arnott

__________________
15 GMs (keep 25 before the draft and can't have more than 30)
Pts only
Start 9F, 1 rookie, 5D and 1G

F : Iginla, Marleau, Eriksson, Berglund, Jagr, Kunitz, Kopitar, Marchand, Hossa
Rookie : Schultz
D : Carlson, Campbell, S. Weber, Seidenberg, Gonchar
G : Lehtonen

Bench : Hudler, Colborne, A. McDonald, Selanne, Zidlicky, Orlov, Lindback, Luongo, Halak

Minor : Weiss, Jurco, Jarnkrok, Kaberle, Lack

I must have been thinking of baked beans (brain farts)- either that or about SuperLuke. Hey, where did my one and only karma point go?:lol:

Post edited by: Stephane Richer, at: 2007/07/10 12:37

__________________
My keeper squad on this 10 team, no positional requirement league (except 1 goalie and 1 NHL team). Points only: Parise, Kopitar, Hemsky, Brunette, J Staal, Okposo, Doan, Roy, O.Jokinen, Giroux, Krejci, Oshie, Eberle, Little, Filpulla, Steen, Filatov, Hudler, H.Lundqvist, + NHL Team LA.