In a keeper league, where goals are 2 points, assists are 1 point, should I trade Sedin, who is coming off a career year, for Cammalleri, who is a few years younger and had as many goals?

I am assuming you are referring to Daniel Sedin versus Henrik Sedin?
If it is Daniel, I would be inclined to lean towards Cammalleri simply for the fact that the Canucks need another line to score and I think the Kings have a better offensive cast around Cammalleri. Naslund had a tough year last season and the Sedin line was the only one that scored essentially on a consistent basis.

__________________
12 Team H2H Keeper League - Scoresheet Hockey
Weekly Lineup: 3 fwd lines, 4 defensemen, 1 goalie
1st line gets 100% of points earned, 2nd line 80%, 3rd line 60%
Forward/D-men Stats: G, A, +/-, PM, PPG, SHG
Goalie Stats: Minutes played, GA, SA
Team: Blind Side Hitters
2011-12 Protections:
C Datsyuk, Kopitar, M. Richards
LW Zetterberg, Franzen, Kulemin
RW Brown, Voracek, Kessel
D Lidstrom, Visnovsky, Yandle
Young Players: RW Eberle, LW Paajarvi, D Goligoski

Yes, sorry for not specifying, DANIEL SEDIN

It is funny you mention Daniel Sedin b/c like you, I am in a keeper league as well and I have both Sedins on my squad. I\'ve been trying to shop Henrik Sedin and nobody has any remote interest, but when I mention Daniel, other owners\' \"ears\" go up. Age wise, Mike C is 25 years old compared to Daniel who is 29 years old. The age thing doesn\'t bother me too much. Daniel is more of the goal scorer of the Sedins, while Henrik dishes out a lot of assists. Right now I am protecting the Sedin twins.
It is hard to say Cammalleri or Sedin? Who else are you protecting on your team?

__________________
12 Team H2H Keeper League - Scoresheet Hockey
Weekly Lineup: 3 fwd lines, 4 defensemen, 1 goalie
1st line gets 100% of points earned, 2nd line 80%, 3rd line 60%
Forward/D-men Stats: G, A, +/-, PM, PPG, SHG
Goalie Stats: Minutes played, GA, SA
Team: Blind Side Hitters
2011-12 Protections:
C Datsyuk, Kopitar, M. Richards
LW Zetterberg, Franzen, Kulemin
RW Brown, Voracek, Kessel
D Lidstrom, Visnovsky, Yandle
Young Players: RW Eberle, LW Paajarvi, D Goligoski

its a full keeper league, and btw, i thought the sedins were 27 years old.

:evil: damn double post!

Post edited by: SabresEdge, at: 2007/07/09 12:58

actually their 26, Sep 26 1980

IslanderFan - Who else are you looking at protecting on your team? Sorry for the goof of the age.

__________________
12 Team H2H Keeper League - Scoresheet Hockey
Weekly Lineup: 3 fwd lines, 4 defensemen, 1 goalie
1st line gets 100% of points earned, 2nd line 80%, 3rd line 60%
Forward/D-men Stats: G, A, +/-, PM, PPG, SHG
Goalie Stats: Minutes played, GA, SA
Team: Blind Side Hitters
2011-12 Protections:
C Datsyuk, Kopitar, M. Richards
LW Zetterberg, Franzen, Kulemin
RW Brown, Voracek, Kessel
D Lidstrom, Visnovsky, Yandle
Young Players: RW Eberle, LW Paajarvi, D Goligoski

Daniel is gonna get better yet but the if in this ointment is another line mate to up the Octane on the Twins line and boost his points by 15 or so. Someone to draw checking attention away from him. I think he will top out at around 45 goals and if the quality line mate arrives 100 pts.
Cammalleri is a little younger and may have a better immediate setup for pts..he shoots a ton and he will score some.. I own him and hope for around 90 pts this season prolly hi 30\'s for goals but if things really gel for him could possibly do 100 pts. I have a feelin their PP is gonna be sick!

__________________
Yahoo Keeper Team - STD Cats
C- Thornton, Backstrom, Kesler, Turris, Savard
L- Vanek, Burrows, Hartnell, Lucic , Leino
R- Brown, Pavelski, Ericksson, Holmstrom, Little
D- Chara, Rafalski, Weber, Edler, Letang, Bieksa,
G- H. Lundqvist, Miller, Rinne,

Prospects- Bowmman CAR, Glennie DAL, LeBlanc MTL, Ferraro DET, Tangradi PIT, Yip COL, Kuznetsov WAS, Neuvirth WAS

League Champion 07, 08, 09,