Hey Guys, i need your help today. My heart is too much of a factor when it comes to the habs and I don't know if I can see the forest for the trees.

I've been offered the following:
Galchenyuk & Carlson or McBain

for
Tarasenko & a dead body

in the end, who will be the best keeper?

League is long term keeper, mostly straight up points and most of the details are in the signature.
thanks in advance and Rep will be given when possible.
LouisT

__________________
LouisT
Keeper League -- Long Term
G=1, A=1, +/-=.5, SHG=1
W=2,L=-1,SO=2,SV=.10,GA=-.75

Active Roster
F: Grigorenko, Stamkos, Perron, Tarasenko, Crosby, Williams, KoivuM, Semin, Huberdeau, Pouliot, Cole, Clarkson
D: Keith, Markov, Despres, Kronwall, Kostka, Faulk
G: Crawford, Holtby
Bench Roster
F: Kuznetsov, Havlat, Vrbata, Anisimov, Forsberg
D: Pitkanen, Mitchell, Doughty, Tyutin
G:Allen, Reimer

any input anyone?

__________________
LouisT
Keeper League -- Long Term
G=1, A=1, +/-=.5, SHG=1
W=2,L=-1,SO=2,SV=.10,GA=-.75

Active Roster
F: Grigorenko, Stamkos, Perron, Tarasenko, Crosby, Williams, KoivuM, Semin, Huberdeau, Pouliot, Cole, Clarkson
D: Keith, Markov, Despres, Kronwall, Kostka, Faulk
G: Crawford, Holtby
Bench Roster
F: Kuznetsov, Havlat, Vrbata, Anisimov, Forsberg
D: Pitkanen, Mitchell, Doughty, Tyutin
G:Allen, Reimer

I think they're very comparable talents with similar upsides. Gal + Carlson is a bit much, and I think the Tarasenko owner is trying to squeeze them out of you. Just do a 1 for 1 trade- there's no need to give up a promising young D as well. If this sours the trade offer, then it's no big deal - you have a future stud in Gal.

__________________
16 team H2H (We keep everyone)
Positions - 2C, 2LW, 2RW, 4D, 2G, 1Util, 11 Bench, No Farm (We just keep prospects on the bench)

Scoring Cats
G ,A, +/-, PIM, PPP, SOG, Hits
Wins, Saves, SV%, GAA, SO

Year 1 = 2/16
Year 2 = 13/16
Last year = 4/16

C-Crosby, Lecavalier, Ott (LW), Schwartz, Matthias, Toffoli, Leino (LW)
L-Michalek (RW), Pacrioretty, Hagelin
R- Gallagher, Neil, Read,
D- Markov, Rielly, Wisniewski, Hamilton, Fraser, Dumba, Beauchemin, Trouba, Barrie
G-Fleury, Bryzgalov, Ward, S.Mason, Enroth,

Thanks Shawnee but the Tarasenko owner is me, this is the offer that was sent to me. Guess that means you think i should prolly do it eh?

__________________
LouisT
Keeper League -- Long Term
G=1, A=1, +/-=.5, SHG=1
W=2,L=-1,SO=2,SV=.10,GA=-.75

Active Roster
F: Grigorenko, Stamkos, Perron, Tarasenko, Crosby, Williams, KoivuM, Semin, Huberdeau, Pouliot, Cole, Clarkson
D: Keith, Markov, Despres, Kronwall, Kostka, Faulk
G: Crawford, Holtby
Bench Roster
F: Kuznetsov, Havlat, Vrbata, Anisimov, Forsberg
D: Pitkanen, Mitchell, Doughty, Tyutin
G:Allen, Reimer

Not a fan of either Carlson or Mcbain. Is there another D option you could squeeze out of him?

__________________
Bigbabybuda is the Hawking of fantasy hockey. Greatest hockey mind of our generation!

I'd do it and go with Galchenyuk and Carlson.

__________________
Points only keeper league
7 teams
28 keepers
Weekly line up: 12 F / 6 D / 2 G
Goalie stats: W=2 / SO=2

Haha, oops. Yeah, I'd say go for it. Unless I'm mistaken, it looks like forward positions don't matter, so you wont even have to worry about trading a RW for a C.

__________________
16 team H2H (We keep everyone)
Positions - 2C, 2LW, 2RW, 4D, 2G, 1Util, 11 Bench, No Farm (We just keep prospects on the bench)

Scoring Cats
G ,A, +/-, PIM, PPP, SOG, Hits
Wins, Saves, SV%, GAA, SO

Year 1 = 2/16
Year 2 = 13/16
Last year = 4/16

C-Crosby, Lecavalier, Ott (LW), Schwartz, Matthias, Toffoli, Leino (LW)
L-Michalek (RW), Pacrioretty, Hagelin
R- Gallagher, Neil, Read,
D- Markov, Rielly, Wisniewski, Hamilton, Fraser, Dumba, Beauchemin, Trouba, Barrie
G-Fleury, Bryzgalov, Ward, S.Mason, Enroth,

I'd have no problem with that deal in a points only; but I'd really rather a D-man just a step up from Carlson or McBain. But if forced to choose between those two, I'd rather Carlson.

__________________
14 Team H2H Dynasty League (14 keepers, 21-man roster, no farm)
G, A, PPP, SOG, BS, +/-, GAA, W, SV%

C: Giroux/B.Richards/Ennis/Cullen/Grigorenko
W: Ovechkin/Neal/Nash/Skinner/Eriksson/Silfverberg/Samuelsson(IR)
D: Doughty/Boyle/Faulk/Seabrook/Martin(IR)/Seidenberg/Brodin
G: Fleury/Markstrom/Lehner/Khudobin

I'd take Galy straight up....and I'm a Leafs fan who doesn't own him in any league so you KNOW my bias isn't playing into this

Take it and run bud!

__________________
13 team Roto keeper league 12 F, 6D, 2G, G,A,+/-, PIMS, Hits, TOI(D), GAA, SV%, (Forwards are forwards, no distinction between L,R,C)

F) Ovechkin, Stamkos, Kane, Ryan, Clarkson, Couture, Ribeiro, Moulson, Van Riemsdyk, Orr, B. Morrow, R.Malone
D) S. Weber, Phaneuf, Subban, Shattenkirk, J. Johnson, Hedman
G) Rask, Khudobin
IR) RNH