Originally Posted by VincentVega

Uh, is everyone forgetting Souray's history? Injury-prone, extremely inconsistent performer. In the last 5 years, he's only put up more than 21 points once. He's had a hot start this year, I'd bet he doesn't sustain it. I'm talking Faulk here, who is somewhat underrated right now.

Originally Posted by LawMan

Easily Souray over Faulk for me. Souray seems to have revitalized himself in Anaheim. Their was never a doubt that he had a big shot but the rest of his game has come together meaning he's getting much more icetime (more chanes for HITs and PIMs). I'd expect them to be close with Souray getting slightly more points. The big edge is that Souray picks up PIMs and HITs in large numbers. I wouldn't base the decision on SH time, for one SH points are few and far between and more importantly SH points are rarely scored by defencemen who usually don't cross the redline during a penalty kill.

Desharnais
Roy
Fisher

These are all pretty close. Desharnais started really slow but has the most upside and has started to pick it up along with the entire Habs team.

Originally Posted by VincentVega

Uh, is everyone forgetting Souray's history? Injury-prone, extremely inconsistent performer. In the last 5 years, he's only put up more than 21 points once. He's had a hot start this year, I'd bet he doesn't sustain it. I'm talking Faulk here, who is somewhat underrated right now.