Should I drop Cal Clutterbuck for Brayden Schenn in my league?

They are both about equal in terms of hits and blocked shots (something my league weighs heavily). They seemingly both get similar ice time per night as well.

I guess I'm asking is who is in a better situation? Does Schenn have more upside?

__________________
One-year, 8 team league. Head to Head.

Skating Cats: Goals (3), Assists (2), Plus/Minus (1), PIMS (.3), Hits & Blocked Shots (1), plus GWG, SHG, PPG.

Goalie Cats: Wins (5), SO (5), OT Loss (2), GA (-1), Sv (.2)

Team "Dekeing on the Edge of Town"

F- David Backes, Ryan Callahan, Evander Kane, Anze Kopitar, Matt Martin, Steve Ott, Zach Parise, PA Parenteau
D- Shea Weber, Brent Seabrook, Luke Schenn, Ladislav Smid, Slava Voynov, Marc Staal (IR)

G- Tukka Rask, Sergei Bobrovsky, Ilya Bryzgalov, Anderson (off IR now)