My main issue is trying to figure out the values of goalies on good teams but face time-share situations, versus goalies on worse/bad teams, but solid starting roles.

Example, Halak vs Hiller?

I'm in a keeper league, basic H2H cats, goalie cats are Wins, SA%, GAA, Shutouts.

The kept goalies are...

Lundqvist (mine), Rinne, Quick, Howard, Bryzgalov, Price, Lehtonen, Rask, Schneider, Fleury, Kipper, and Niemi.

I have the 6th overall pick and 18th overall pick, and obviously need to grab a goalie in the first round, but also thinking about perhaps grabbing another goalie in the second round.

Here's a crop of available tenders, maybe you guys can help me rank these guys... I'm really not sure whether to give the nod to someone in timeshare, or a workhorse.

Smith
Ward
Miller

(I expect all three to be gone by my pick)

Expected "safe" starters:

Brodeur
Hiller
Varlamov
PAvelec
Crawford
Lindback

Starters facing potential time-share:

Anderson
Backstrom
Dubnyk

Time-Share:

Halak
Elliot
Holtby
Neuvirth
Luongo

What do you guys think? You can just rank your top 5 (excluding Miller, Ward, and Smith) or you can do the whole shebang.

Any help is DEFINITELY appreciated!! Thanks.

Luongo
Hiller
Pavelec
Halak
Anderson