I Get
Dubinsky
Lupul
Smith (D on DET)

He Gets
Voracek
Michalek

Good Trade or No?

In multi-cat, Dubinsky/Lupul/Smith is better side.

In points-only, Voracek/Michalek is possibly better side... maybe... I don't know... maybe not. It's close.

To get a better answer add league scoring categories, roster #s. Also assuming you have a max roster you'll need to drop a 3rd player, who will that be (post your roster if you're not sure)?

__________________
12 team H-2-H 1 year league, daily roster 3 goalie start minimum
2xC, 2xRW, 2xLW, 4xD, 3xUtil, 2xG, 5 Bench
G, A, P, +/-, PIM, PPP, SHP, GWG, Hits, W, SV%, GAA
C: Stamkos,Thornton, Riberio, Stepan, Desharnais, Clune
LW: Moulson, Dupuis, Prust,
RW: Kessel, P. Kane, Wheeler, Stempniak
D: Hamonic, Zidlicky, Franson, Muzzin
G: Bryzgalov, Hiller, Fasth

Not sure it's enough to make me want to part with the best ranked defense prospect not named Justin Schultz. Seems like a bunch of smoke and mirros with a bunch of very good hockey players to try snatch a fantastic young defender from you.

__________________
Team:
C - Tavares, Getzlaf, Ribeiro, (C/R)
L - Hall, Semin, Macdonald(C/L), Healtey(L/R),
R - Perry, Yakupov, Voracek, Voracek, Williams, Boyes
D - Streit, OEL, Edler, Karlsson, B. Smith, Beauchemin, Seidenberg
G - Rinne, Bryzgalov, Anderson, Bernier, Vokoun
10 Team Keeper league with Yahoo

Roster (14 Kept Players): C, C, LW, LW, RW, RW, D, D, D, D, Util, Util, G, G,

(Weighted Category Points: see below).

Skaters -
(Points: G a/o A) 6
(+/-) 3
(PIM) 1
(PPP) 5
(GWG) 5

Goaltenders
(W) 15
(GA) -10
(SV) 1
(SHO) 15

I think that the poster would get Smith...not the other way around.

Obviously losing Voracek hurts, Lupul is capable of putting up good numbers if healthy.

As per the other posters if you let us know PTS structure it would go along way, also, what does acquiring Lupul and Dubinsky do to your cap...is there a cap?

Without more details it is hard to say, but, I am big on Smith.

__________________
Salary Cap League:
15 Team, G, A,+/-, W-2, OTL,SO-3
30 max, 21 weekly active roster (12F, 7D, 2G)
Note: Our league is 1 year behind in terms of available players and salary. Salary doesn't change for length of Pool contract.

Team:
F-Ovechkin,Eriksson(*), Regin,Stamkos(*), Brouwer(*),B.Ryan(*), Dalpe, Kadri(*), Eller(*), Pacioretty, Iginla, H.Sedin, D.Sedin
D-
B.Burns(*),Goligoski, McBain, TJ Brodie(*), Blum, Schenn, Postma
G-
Price(*),Bryz

(*) = Multi year deal

My Bad...same answer, only this time it's directed at you. I'd take the Smith Side.

__________________
Team:
C - Tavares, Getzlaf, Ribeiro, (C/R)
L - Hall, Semin, Macdonald(C/L), Healtey(L/R),
R - Perry, Yakupov, Voracek, Voracek, Williams, Boyes
D - Streit, OEL, Edler, Karlsson, B. Smith, Beauchemin, Seidenberg
G - Rinne, Bryzgalov, Anderson, Bernier, Vokoun
10 Team Keeper league with Yahoo

Roster (14 Kept Players): C, C, LW, LW, RW, RW, D, D, D, D, Util, Util, G, G,

(Weighted Category Points: see below).

Skaters -
(Points: G a/o A) 6
(+/-) 3
(PIM) 1
(PPP) 5
(GWG) 5

Goaltenders
(W) 15
(GA) -10
(SV) 1
(SHO) 15

My Team
3 Evgeni Malkin, Pit C
13 Pekka Rinne, Nsh G
28 Rick Nash, NYR LW
33 Jordan Eberle, Edm RW
48 Martin St. Louis, TB RW
53 Joe Thornton, SJ C
68 P.K. Subban, Mon D
73 Matt Moulson, NYI LW
88 Tyler Ennis, Buf C
93 Jakub Voracek, Phi RW
108 Bobby Ryan, Ana LW
113 Drew Doughty, LA D
128 Jonathan Huberdeau, Fla C
133 James Wisniewski, Cls D
148 Tyler Myers, Buf D
153 Marek Zidlicky, NJ D
168 Milan Michalek, Ott LW
173 Dennis Seidenberg, Bos D
188 Travis Hamonic, NYI D
193 Nick Leddy, Chi D
208 P.A. Parenteau, Col RW
213 Miikka Kiprusoff, Cgy G
228 Corey Crawford, Chi G

His Team
9 Claude Giroux, Phi C
19 Patrick Sharp, Chi RW
22 Jimmy Howard, Det G
39 Henrik Zetterberg, Det C
42 Patrick Marleau, SJ LW
59 Teemu Selanne, Ana RW
62 Joffrey Lupul, Tor LW
79 Patrice Bergeron, Bos C
82 Jack Johnson, Cls D
99 Kimmo Timonen, Phi D
102 Alex Burrows, Van RW
119 Brandon Dubinsky, Cls LW
122 Mark Giordano, Cgy D
139 Craig Anderson, Ott G
142 Ryan Kesler*, Van C
159 Martin Havlat, SJ RW
162 Cam Fowler, Ana D
179 Brendan Smith, Det D
182 Erik Johnson, Col D
199 Wojtek Wolski, Wsh LW
202 Josh Harding, Min G
219 Tomas Kaberle, Mon D
222 Jamie McBain, Car D

Cats Are
G A +/- PTS PIM PPG SOG PPP

No CAP

Your posting in a 1 year league forums so I assume that you don't get to keep anyone at the end of this...

I changed my opinion, I don't think Smith get's you enough points in a 1 year league to make this worth it, he is the best player coming back IMO (Long term)

CLB and TOR have bad +/-, so that is a negative as well.

Keep Voracek and Michalek

__________________
Salary Cap League:
15 Team, G, A,+/-, W-2, OTL,SO-3
30 max, 21 weekly active roster (12F, 7D, 2G)
Note: Our league is 1 year behind in terms of available players and salary. Salary doesn't change for length of Pool contract.

Team:
F-Ovechkin,Eriksson(*), Regin,Stamkos(*), Brouwer(*),B.Ryan(*), Dalpe, Kadri(*), Eller(*), Pacioretty, Iginla, H.Sedin, D.Sedin
D-
B.Burns(*),Goligoski, McBain, TJ Brodie(*), Blum, Schenn, Postma
G-
Price(*),Bryz

(*) = Multi year deal

well idk if we are going to do another season because its a league with some friends and we might keep it going. If that helps a little?

Didn't catch that either. B. Smith's value is in a keeper format. Minimizing his value here means I'd stick with what you have.

__________________
Team:
C - Tavares, Getzlaf, Ribeiro, (C/R)
L - Hall, Semin, Macdonald(C/L), Healtey(L/R),
R - Perry, Yakupov, Voracek, Voracek, Williams, Boyes
D - Streit, OEL, Edler, Karlsson, B. Smith, Beauchemin, Seidenberg
G - Rinne, Bryzgalov, Anderson, Bernier, Vokoun
10 Team Keeper league with Yahoo

Roster (14 Kept Players): C, C, LW, LW, RW, RW, D, D, D, D, Util, Util, G, G,

(Weighted Category Points: see below).

Skaters -
(Points: G a/o A) 6
(+/-) 3
(PIM) 1
(PPP) 5
(GWG) 5

Goaltenders
(W) 15
(GA) -10
(SV) 1
(SHO) 15