G,A,+/-,PIM,PPP,GWG

The guy sent me some options.

1) Callahan and Hamilton - for - Kulikov, Gunnarsson, a 2014 1st (yours), and two that you pick from (Hartikainen, Zibanejad, Reinhart, Holland, Tokarski, Roy, my 2013 1st)

2) Callahan and Hamilton - for - Kulikov, Stepan, and 2014 1st (yours)

3) Callahan and Hamilton - for - Kulikov, Krejci, and 2014 1st (yours)

4) Callahan and Hamilton - for - Kulikov, Cole and 2014 2nd (mine)

Callahan and Dougie are mine. Are any worth trading them for.

Thanks

I would keep Callahan and Hamilton I don't like the either of the trade for you.

__________________
6 teams leagues winner in 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2nd in my one year league
PTS only, goalies 2pts for win +1pt for SO
Keeper 5 forwards 3 defense players+calder candidate are free keeper, we dress 12fwd,4d,2g,9bn, weekly changement.
C: Kopitar, Backstrom, Seguin, Roy, Ribeiro.
W: St louis, Kessel, Skinner, Semin, Ryan, Voracek, Ennis .
D: Karlsson, MDZ, Streit, OEL.
G: Lundquist, Rinne.
Bench: Holtby, Ward, Okposo, Stastny, Schultz, Tarasenko, D.Brown, Granlund, Huberdeau, JVR

hummm... good one...

Are you contending this year?

I really, really like Hamilton but I really like option 2 (and/or 3). I think we just start to see the surface of Kulikov. Dito for Stepan. Adding a 1st rounder is very good but we need to know what's available in the draft...

2 things for sure, I would discard 1 and 4.

But as I say, for better advice, can you tell us what your team look like and if you are contending this year?

__________________
__________________
C- Krejci, Zetterberg, Gagner
C(r)-Stamkos, Eller, Ennis, Namestnikov, Couturier
W-Nash, Parise, Wheeler, Brown, J. Carter, Hemsky, Franzen
W(r)-Tatar, Bjugstad, Rattie
D-Yandle, Edler, J. Johnson
D(r)-Ekman-Larsson, Hamilton, Elliot, Ceci
G- Rask, Price, Ward, Dubnyk

KEEPER (6 each year + 10 rookies under 23), 11 Teams
F+D : Points only
G : 2pts for SO
3 C, 4 W, 3 D + 2 G

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

__________________
Gatineau Scorpinos Roster

Forwards: Crosby, Landeskog, Ovechkin, D.Sedin, Toews, Wheeler.
Defence: Byfuglion, Doughty, Keith, Subban.
Goalies: Howard, Pavelec, Price.

Rookies: Galchenyuk, Scheifele, Schutlz.
Prospects: Grigorenko, J.Kea, Reinhart, M. Subban, D. Thrower, Trouba.

Bench*

2x Regular Season Champion in the WFHL the Gatineau/Hull Scorpions.
2007-08, 2011-12
0x Playoff champion.

F.F: http://www.fleaflicker.com/user?userId=592340 Take a look at my Teams

Follow Me https://twitter.com/#!/MRHOCKEYLOVER87

16 team league

I am contending. I have goalies like Lehtonen and Halak. Notable forwards are Doan,Callahan,Granlund,Joe Thornton,Ryan Clowe,Patrice Bergeron,Joffrey Lupul, Alex Tanguay,Radim Vrbata. Notable d-man are Cam Fowler, Brent Seabrook,Mark Streit, Joni Pitkanen,Kyle Quincey, Dougie Hamilton.

Not quite sure what the hell this means.

Anyways, getting back to your trade question. Looking at the options he presented to you, I really dont like any of them for what you are losing.

I would just keep what I have. For me to move Cally and Hamilton, the offer would have to knock my socks off and none of those offers really knock my socks off.

If you had a good idea where the draft picks would be in each round, that may help (if you were getting the 1st overall pick, that would make a difference) but without knowing, its too hard to judge.

__________________
10 Team, Points Only, $$ League, Keep 20/25 at seasons end
25 Man Roster, top 20 monthly point getters count
Goalie points W=2pt L=-1pt SHO=2pt

Stamkos, Tavares, Hall, Couture, Hanzal, Wheeler, Stastny, Versteeg, Fisher, Hornqvist, Eriksson, Hodgson, Setoguchi, Turris, Steen, Letang, DRoy, Yakupov, Grabner, Byfuglien, Baertschi

G-Rask, Halak, Schneider

PIM
Callahan 100%
Krejci 50%
Stepan 33%

Pts
Krejci 100%
Stepan 90%
Callahan 85%

PPP
Krejci – First unit
Stepan - Second unit
Callahan - Second unit

GWG & +/-
???

With that said, I think Callahan have an (albeit very small) edge over both Krejci and Stepan because of the PIM department. But Krejci should rack-up more PPP also so... Overall, it's pretty much a wash IMO.

So the key is Hamilton for Kulikov + 1st rounder. Hamilton SHOULD be a beast in all your cats setting. Key word is «*should*». While Kulikov won't produce as many PIM than him, his pts total shall be close.

I don't know how many D you dress but Kulikov (for this year mind you) rank behind Streit, Seabrook and Fowler. Very close to Pitkanen. So, do you NEED him (Kulikov) this year?

Not knowing how your keeper works (rookie, farm, etc.) the second question is : Is Hamilton «*free*» to keep versus a keeper slot for Kulikov? For the first rounder, I don't know what's available in your draft but getting a first rounder is always nice. But in regard to the information that I have in hand, I woudn't make that deal.

__________________
__________________
C- Krejci, Zetterberg, Gagner
C(r)-Stamkos, Eller, Ennis, Namestnikov, Couturier
W-Nash, Parise, Wheeler, Brown, J. Carter, Hemsky, Franzen
W(r)-Tatar, Bjugstad, Rattie
D-Yandle, Edler, J. Johnson
D(r)-Ekman-Larsson, Hamilton, Elliot, Ceci
G- Rask, Price, Ward, Dubnyk

KEEPER (6 each year + 10 rookies under 23), 11 Teams
F+D : Points only
G : 2pts for SO
3 C, 4 W, 3 D + 2 G

So? How did it turn out?

__________________
__________________
C- Krejci, Zetterberg, Gagner
C(r)-Stamkos, Eller, Ennis, Namestnikov, Couturier
W-Nash, Parise, Wheeler, Brown, J. Carter, Hemsky, Franzen
W(r)-Tatar, Bjugstad, Rattie
D-Yandle, Edler, J. Johnson
D(r)-Ekman-Larsson, Hamilton, Elliot, Ceci
G- Rask, Price, Ward, Dubnyk

KEEPER (6 each year + 10 rookies under 23), 11 Teams
F+D : Points only
G : 2pts for SO
3 C, 4 W, 3 D + 2 G