So I get

Kovalchuk, Holtby and the 6th pick waiver draft

for

My

Neal, Poulin and the 12th pick waiver draft

thoughts?

it is a keep 10 at end of season and 10 in the farm.

__________________
Lorenzin

Team Habitants

C - Tavares, Stamkos
LW - Hall, Ryan
RW - Seguin
D - Doughty, Pietrangelo
G - Price
F - Crosby


Team St. Louis Blues

C - Tavares, Toews
LW - EKane, Hall
RW - Neal, Seguin, PKane
D - Yandle
G - Price, Rinne

What quality of players are available in the waiver draft, that's a key question here although I favour the Kovalchuk side at first glance because of Holtby.

__________________
- WHL colour man and scout and former writer for fantasyhockeycoach.com

Twitter @ http://twitter.com/#!/WHLFromAbove

http://forums.dobbersports.com/showthread.php?t=136622

here is a thread i posted the other day with that info...

__________________
Lorenzin

Team Habitants

C - Tavares, Stamkos
LW - Hall, Ryan
RW - Seguin
D - Doughty, Pietrangelo
G - Price
F - Crosby


Team St. Louis Blues

C - Tavares, Toews
LW - EKane, Hall
RW - Neal, Seguin, PKane
D - Yandle
G - Price, Rinne

Looks like a depth forward at the twelve spot, and somone solid at 6.

I'd take that offer. Kovy and Neal should be a wash, with Kovy having an edge IMO.

I will take Holtby over Poulin as well.

Do it.

I agree with everyone on this trade

Kovy+Holtby > Neal+Poulin
and obviously
#6 > #12

Kovy and Neal are fairly similar.. if you value one over the other, it cant be by that much (a case can be made on both sides).. all the other factors in the trade make it a win for you. do it

__________________
Yahoo H2H - 16 Team Dynasty yr 8 - 3C 6W 2Util 4D 2G (p/week)
G, A, PPP, +/-, PIM, GWG
W, GAA, SV%, SHO
C- H. Sedin, Zetterberg, M. Richards
W- D. Sedin, Kovalchuk, Ryan, Lucic, Marchand, Wheeler
Util- Stewart, Kadri, Michalek, Bartschi, Atkinson, Strome, Etem
D- Campbell, Ehrhoff, Garrison, Schultz, B. Smith, Dumba
G- Miller, Smith, Ward

Yahoo H2H - 12 Team Keeper - 2011, 2012 Champ - Keep 6 - *last years keepers*
start 2C 2RW 2LW 4D 1G weekly
G, A, P, +/-, PPG, SHG, GWG
W, GAA, SV%, SHO
C- Malkin, Backstrom
LW- Benn, Duchene
RW- Eberle, St. Louis
D- Subban
G- Rinne

SO the deal has been changed slightly, but i am leaning towards accepting...

i get
jeff carter, braden holtby and adam larsson

i give
james neal

any thought on that move? i am really needing some help here...

Stat Categories:
Goals (G) Assists (A) Plus/Minus (+/-) Penalty Minutes (PIM) Power Play Points (PPP) Shots on Goal (SOG) Game Winning Goals (GWG) Shorthanded Points (SHP)
Wins (W) Goals Against Average (GAA) Save Percentage (SV%) Shutouts (SO)

The league will use the Yahoo head-to-head (H2H) scoring

__________________
Lorenzin

Team Habitants

C - Tavares, Stamkos
LW - Hall, Ryan
RW - Seguin
D - Doughty, Pietrangelo
G - Price
F - Crosby


Team St. Louis Blues

C - Tavares, Toews
LW - EKane, Hall
RW - Neal, Seguin, PKane
D - Yandle
G - Price, Rinne

This is a significant drop off from the previous offer with Kovy in it.. I'd do the Kovy trade but not if its including Carter... Holtby and Larsson probably wont even make your top 10 keeper list.. i just see this as watering down your team.. Id stay with Neal or push to get Kovy back into it

__________________
Yahoo H2H - 16 Team Dynasty yr 8 - 3C 6W 2Util 4D 2G (p/week)
G, A, PPP, +/-, PIM, GWG
W, GAA, SV%, SHO
C- H. Sedin, Zetterberg, M. Richards
W- D. Sedin, Kovalchuk, Ryan, Lucic, Marchand, Wheeler
Util- Stewart, Kadri, Michalek, Bartschi, Atkinson, Strome, Etem
D- Campbell, Ehrhoff, Garrison, Schultz, B. Smith, Dumba
G- Miller, Smith, Ward

Yahoo H2H - 12 Team Keeper - 2011, 2012 Champ - Keep 6 - *last years keepers*
start 2C 2RW 2LW 4D 1G weekly
G, A, P, +/-, PPG, SHG, GWG
W, GAA, SV%, SHO
C- Malkin, Backstrom
LW- Benn, Duchene
RW- Eberle, St. Louis
D- Subban
G- Rinne

The first offer, you were winning the deal.
Now you are definatley losing the deal. Carter is really overrated, kinda like Nash, but way worse.

Holtby still doesn't have the starting gig yet, and even when he does, his leash will be very short. Larsson hasn't done much of anything, and I don't see that changing soon. Keep Neal or get Kovy back in the deal.

__________________

10 Team NHL Keeper League (Keep 6)
Points only (F/D 1pt/G 1pt/A, Goalie 2pt/W 3pt/SO)
Starters: 12 Forwards, 6 Defense, 2 Goalie
(82 game cap at each position)
Bench: 3 Any Position
No IR

F- Giroux, Backstrom, Tavares, Kovalchuk, Getzlaf, Benn, Iginla, M.Koivu, Hartnell, Carter, Cammalleri, Callahan

D- Byfuglien, Green, Boyle, Goligoski, Visnovsky, Wizniewski

G- Rask, Elliott

BN- Brodeur, Saad, Beauchemin

Picks - 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17

***2012-2013 League Champion***
***2011-2012 Runner Up***
***2010-2011 League Champion***

I'd do the first deal. The second, i'd easily turn down.

__________________
League: Yahoo 20 Team Dynasty, H2H (4C, 8W, 6D, 1G)
Cats: +/-, FOW, A, G, GWG, PPP, SHP, SOG, S, SPct, W, GAA

C: Kopitar,Nyquist,J.Staal,Strome
W: Atkinson,Benn,Brunner,Huberdeau
Iginla,Kessel,Seguin,Selanne
D: Beaulieu,DeKeyser,Despres,D.Hamilton,Leopold,Salo
G: M.A.Fleury
Bench: B.Bennett,B.Gordon,Petrovic,Stalberg - J.Bernier, J.Howard
Prospects: Andrighetto,V.Arvidsson,G.Carey,Filatov,Kabanov,Kuhnhackl,Omark,R.Schwartz
Shalunov,Stransky
Clendening,Deslauriers,Gauthier-Leduc,J.Morrow,R.Murphy,Postma,Reilly -- P.Bartosak,N.Lundstrom,J.Olkinuora,A.Wilcox