In a keeper league, points only (goals worth 2, assists worth 1 for D-men), who do people like here?? I could maybe go for the win next year or two. Thanks very much!!

Short-term I would prefer Wisniewski, especially if you want to take a title shot next season. As you are in a points-only-league, you don't need to worry about his +/- playing for Columbus. I like McBain's potential as well, maybe he is making a huge step forward next year but maybe it's going to take another one or a change of scenery for a huge breakthrough year. The safer option seems to be Wisniewski here.

Cheers,
Doc

__________________

Yahoo 12 Team H2H Keeper League. (11 Keepers, 9 C/RW/LW/D + 2 G) - Year 7
3C 3LW 3RW 5D 2UTIL 2G 5 BE 2 IR.
G,A,P,+-,PIM,PPP,SHP,GWG,SOG,SH%,FW,HIT; W,GAA,SV,SV%,SO.

Team: Mannhyme Mobsters
(C) Zetterberg (LW), Oshie (RW), Stepan, Desharnais
(LW) Couture (C), Pacioretty, Ennis (C), B?rtschi
(RW) Seguin (C), Wheeler, Okposo, Johansen (C)
(D) Shattenkirk, Goligoski, OEL, Carle, Kronwall, B. Smith
(G) Lundqvist, Backstrom, Schneider

Draft Picks 2012: Round 2,3,3,3,4,5,5,6,9,10

A missing part of the equation is: Who are your other Dmen?

If your betting on either fo these guys to be your number 1 then I don't think you should be going for it. On the other hand if they're going to be no#4 or #5 guys or on the bench it would affect my choice.

Regardless I would prefer Mcbain over Wis going forward. Main reason is the team Wis is on - CBJ will suck real bad if they get rid of Nash in the off season.

__________________
16 Team Limited Keeper:
LW - D. Sedin, Kovalchuk,
C - Malkin, H. Sedin, E. Staal
RW - Perry, St.Louis,
D - Weber, Markov, Kaberle,
G -Halak, Varlamov

I like Wiz since goals are more valuable. Also McBain has more competition (Faulk, Pitkanen - even Harrison and Spacek have gotten some PP love in the past), so might not get on PP1. I think Wiz and Jack Johnson have got to be locks on PP1 in Columbus (as they were on Tuesday).

I do agree with Go Puck Yourself that Columbus is screwed - hell, they're screwed even WITH Nash. But they've still go to score SOME goals, right?

__________________
Icy Dead People

Limited keeper H2H (G A +/- PIM PPP SOG BLK W GAA SV%); 14-teams, 18-man rosters; start 2C, 2LW, 2RW, 6D, 1 Util, 2G; keep 8

C: Getzlaf, Malkin, E. Kane,
LW: Sharp, Hall, Moulson
RW: Ryan, Selanne, Clarkson, Downie
D: Green, Edler, Keith, White, Seidenberg, Giordano [Hamonic IR]
G: Niemi, Crawford