I think only the top 3 is without debate - Luongo, Miller, Lundqvist. Each of those three is clearly unseatable as the team's #1, has proven results, is not past his prime, and plays for a team that is defensively minded enough to avoid situations like Ward and Vokoun have faced in recent years where the result is a great SV% but average, at best, GAA.

For 4 and 5, I think that Thomas belongs. In 2 of the last 3 seasons he's put up Hasek-like numbers. Yes, Rask is the anointed one in Boston and Thomas is getting older, but until he shows signs of skill erosion (I'd argue that two seasons ago doesn't count as it was later revealed that he was playing hurt before losing the job to Rask, yet still put up pretty decent stats) he certainly belongs in this list.

For the other remaining spot I think a viable case could be made for each of Bryzgalov, Fleury, Rinne, or even Quick. I'd omit Price for now, but if he has another season like this past one, he leapfrogs all these guys.

What do you guys think of Halak?

i dunno i think i would rather have rinne than miller

my top 10

Lundqvist
Luongo
Rinne
Thomas
Price
Miller
Bryzgalov
Fleury
Halak
Quick

I think Halak is somewhere from 10th to 15th best keeper goalie to have. He's fighting with the likes of Niemi, Howard, Crawford, Kiprusoff and Lehtonen for that last place in the Top 10. Not elite but really good.

__________________
16 team H2H Dynasty League
G,A,Pts,+/-,PPP,SHP,SOG,PIM,H,BS, W,SV%,GAA,SO
LW: Ryan, JVR, E.Kane, Comeau, M.Martin
C: Berglund, Zajac, Steen, Hanzal
RW: Eriksson, Ryder, Wheeler, Clarkson
D: Karlsson, Hamonic, Kulikov, Del Zotto, Sbisa, Gilbert
G: Price, Lehtonen, Bobrovsky

20 team H2H Dynasty League
G,A,Pts,+/-,PPP,SHP,H,BS, W,Sv,SV%,GAA
LW: Marleau, Benn, Gagne, Fedotenko
C: J. Staal, Zubrus, Cullen, C. Smith
RW: Giroux, Selanne, Wheeler, Nodl, Condra
D: Chara, Pietrangelo, Markov, Larsson, Gorges, Regehr, Morris, Jurcina
G: Miller, Lehtonen

Lundqvist
Miller
Rinne
Price
Bryzgalov

I don't see how you can keep Bryz off this list if we're assuming he goes to Philly.

Lundqvist
Luongo
------------
Price
Halak
Quick
Bryzgalov
Miller
Vokoun
Rinne
Niemi
Hiller
------------
Crawford
Neuvirth
Schneider
Bernier
Rask
Pavelec
Howard
Lehtonen

...something like this based on those 3 tiers is what I think of the goalie situations. Each tier is basically equal to me short-term and unranked, but with slight advantage going to options on better clubs vs. options on weaker clubs.

Wow - Thomas not even in your top 19?

__________________
H2H 10 GMs Keeper: keep up to 4 at cost of draft pick (round in red) G, A,+/-,PIM,SOG,PPP; Wins,GAA,Sv% Start 2C 2R 2L 1 Util 4D 2G, weekly starts
C: Tomáš Plecanec (10), Jonathan Huberdeau (11)
LW: Patrik Eliáš (14), Pascal Dupuis (10) Иlлья Kovalchuk (1), Brandon Saad (10)
RW: Jarome Iginla (3), Phil Kessel (2) Jakub Voráček (9)
Util:
D:Ryan Suter (7), Mike Green (4), Brent Burns (10), Mark Streit, Justin Schultz (12)
G:Craig Anderson (6), Дeвaн Dubnyk (17) Cepгeй Bobrovsky (9), Niklas Bäckström (8)

Rinne over Miller for me too. I like this list except Price would be higher for me.

__________________
H2H 10 GMs Keeper: keep up to 4 at cost of draft pick (round in red) G, A,+/-,PIM,SOG,PPP; Wins,GAA,Sv% Start 2C 2R 2L 1 Util 4D 2G, weekly starts
C: Tomáš Plecanec (10), Jonathan Huberdeau (11)
LW: Patrik Eliáš (14), Pascal Dupuis (10) Иlлья Kovalchuk (1), Brandon Saad (10)
RW: Jarome Iginla (3), Phil Kessel (2) Jakub Voráček (9)
Util:
D:Ryan Suter (7), Mike Green (4), Brent Burns (10), Mark Streit, Justin Schultz (12)
G:Craig Anderson (6), Дeвaн Dubnyk (17) Cepгeй Bobrovsky (9), Niklas Bäckström (8)

Fleury is getting no love whatsoever. I know most people around here think he is overrated but is is still only 26 and he was 7th in Wins, 7th in GAA, and 12th in SVP among goalies that played at least 30 games. Thats without Malkin and Crosby for half the year, and yes I think that has an impact on the teams defence cause if the other team is working hard trying to stop Malkin and Crosby they cant be as offensively minded. Not saying he should be top three but top 10 for sure because of job security.

__________________
ASKL - 10 Team dynasty,G/A=1,PIM=.1,+/- =.2 SOG=.05 (W=2,SO=3) Keep 12F 6D 2G 8BN + farm
F-Perry,Ryan,Giroux,Stastny,Ribeiro,Krejci,Plekanec, JvR,Bergeron,Fleischmann,Grabovski,Cammalleri
D-Letang,Chara,Edler,Boyle,Giordano,Gardiner,
G-Rinne,Crawford
Bench-Bernier,Reimer,Parenteau,Callahan,Downie,Kulemin, Meszaros,Nikitin
Farm- Namestnikov,Khoklachev,Rundblad,Despres,Jensen, L.Adam,Barberio,Galiev,Telegin,Hertl,Aberg

Spoken like a Fleury owner ;/

Seriously - I think you've identified a a phenomenon here: Fleury was spoken of as elite for a bit, and now the backlash has over-corrected. He's about right for #8-11 with these cats. But given the lack of love for him, I'd look to go into a draft hoping to find him with the #11-15 echelon.

__________________
H2H 10 GMs Keeper: keep up to 4 at cost of draft pick (round in red) G, A,+/-,PIM,SOG,PPP; Wins,GAA,Sv% Start 2C 2R 2L 1 Util 4D 2G, weekly starts
C: Tomáš Plecanec (10), Jonathan Huberdeau (11)
LW: Patrik Eliáš (14), Pascal Dupuis (10) Иlлья Kovalchuk (1), Brandon Saad (10)
RW: Jarome Iginla (3), Phil Kessel (2) Jakub Voráček (9)
Util:
D:Ryan Suter (7), Mike Green (4), Brent Burns (10), Mark Streit, Justin Schultz (12)
G:Craig Anderson (6), Дeвaн Dubnyk (17) Cepгeй Bobrovsky (9), Niklas Bäckström (8)