From a points only perspective, thoughts on Eric Johnson vs Cola? Using a standard 3 year window will Johnson get it together and raise his game? Is Cola approaching bandaid boy territory?

__________________
30 team league, 23 man squad, 10 prospects. points only, NHL salary cap. Keepers: 9F, 5D, 1G or 7F, 3D, 2G
Likely Keepers
LW: Hartnell, Datsyuk C: Grabovski, Gagner, RW: Perry, Voracek, Purcell
D: Byfuglien, Carlson, Kronvall G: Fleury, Howard

Prospects: F: Tatar, K. Hayes, McKegg, Watson, Friberg, da Costa D: Taormina, Gustafsson G: Murphy, Kuemper

Regular Season Champion 2010-11
Second place 2011-12

I'm pretty sure CC is widely considered to be a band-aid boy already.
That aside, in a keeper league I would take EJ hands-down.
I know many will say that EJ is turning into more of a two-way defenceman but I still believe 55 points is attainable within a 3-year window.