I'm not at all surprised that the new kid on the block gets the majority of votes around here...
In terms of tools, Yandle is now, what Karlsson owners would like him to develop to... By the time this might (should) happen, I think Phoenix will be improved offensively and Ottawa will regress (sans Alfie).
Yandle today, Yandle tomorrow.
Karlsson benefits today from Gonchar, but in the not too distant future the combo of Yandle and Ekman-Larsson will be scary.

don't forget about goncharov in PHO...not sure Yandle sticks in a couple years due to competition with these future studs.......as stated earlier...great problem to have this year....both will put up decent numbers. not sure your dilemna warrants a roster move.

__________________
budsfan17
_________________________________________
2011/12 Regular Season Champ
5th Year Expansion Team in 12 Team Keeper Pool.
F--Pts (2)
D--Pts (3)
All Skaters -- Hits (.15), BS (.1) PPG/SHG (1), SO GWG (5)
Goal --G (10), A (3), GP (0.15) Saves (.01), W (4), SO (2), OTL (1)

10 Keepers
Malkin, Stamkos, Neal, Spezza, Voracek, Yakupov
Goligoski, Shattenkirk, Del Zotto,
Rinne

+ Annual 15 player draft plus FA pickups