One year, points only. Dang this is a tough one. While I'm at it, how about Benn vs. Williams (LAK) - same parameters.

I just finished my draft and faced a similar question, except mine was a keeper. I took Tavares because he is playing monster minutes, and despite the fact there is less talent around him, he will get his points. I also took Benn in my pool with my last pick. He is doing well with Dallas, and I think will take Brunnstrums position sometime this year. Did you mean Justin Williams? If so, I would take Williams.

__________________
12 Team Keeper, Cap56.7mil, Ptsonly, 10f,5d,2g
F-Kane,Ovechkin,Parise,Skinner,Duchene,Tavares,Benn, B.Schenn,Spezza,Stepan,O'Sullivan,Samuelsson,Filat ov
D-Carlson,Karlsson,Ekman-Larsson,Sanguinetti
G-Luongo, Rask

14 Team Keeper, Cap 56.7mil,Pts only, 9f,4d,2g
F-Malkin,Kopitar,Backstrom,Berglund,St.Louis,B.Schen n,B.Connolly,Weiss,Elias,J.Staal
D-Blum,McBain,Yandle,Shattenkirk
G-Bryzgalov,S.Mason

Tavares by far....far far far and Justin Williams by far as well. No doubt. With kopitar and smyth baby! tavares monster minutes and he's better period.

__________________
Contract Fantrax 14 teams, 8 keepers. 4 max lifers +/-
3C, 3LW, 3RW, 1F. 5D,2G....5Reserves.
Goal heavy. G=3.5 A=2 Add 0.5pts for D.
Goalies:W=3,SO=4,start=2,Save=.1
Shootout Save=.2
C:CROSBY,STAMKOS,TAVARES,
LW:Sedin,MARCHAND,TLUSTY,ELIAS,Whitney
RW:MALKIN,YAKUPOV,Jagr,Brunner
D: BYFUGLIEN,YANDLE,VOYNOV,Carlson,Visnovsky
G:Lundqvist,lehtonen,Pavelec
Minors: Granlund
Baseball
Votto,Cano,hanley,longoria
McCutchen,Stanton,Bautista.
Verlander,Cain,Felix