I\'m in a keeper league, I have a trade offer of Malkin,Recchi,Demtria,K Lehtoten and Paul Ranger, for Thorton,Cheechoo and Fleury.. Please help....

__________________
+/-.gls,assit,Dgls,Dassit,GWG,PPG,PIM,SV%,GAA,Wins
8FD,4D,2G 22 players total,Salary Cap of 58million
Shannon ,Malkin,Connolly,Peverley,Vermette,Frolov,Moulson,
Stewart, Tanguay,Downie,Umberger,
Foster, M Green, Jov,Kaberle,Gilroy,Letang,
Biron, Huet,Conklin, ,Theodore

YOu might have to give more info but from what I can see, the side getting THornton/Cheechoo/Fleury is winning in a very lopsided trade.

__________________
14 GM H2H Salary Cap League (Salaries not Caps)
Stats:G A +/- PIM PPG PPA SHP GWG SOG FW HITS|W GAA SV SV% SHO
Start: 2C,2LW,2RW,4D,2UTIL,2G
Prospect Farm (<92GP skaters, <60 goalies)

Dobber Pro League Wales Division - Roto
Stats: G,A,+/-,PiM,PPP,SOG|W,GAA,Saves
Start: 4C,4L,4R,6D,2G (Weekly changes)
2010 - 3rd place
2009 - 3rd place

If its just points, it might not be as lopsided as you think.
Malkin is every bit as valuable as Thornton with more long term potential

Lehtonen is at least as good as Fleury but playing on a worse team... so it depends whether you are looking for wins or save %, SHO, etc

Demitra and Cheechoo are in the same boat - coming off less than stellar years... both could put up good numbers

So to top it off you get the new PP QB in Tampa in Ranger, along with a 1 yr fix on the wing in Recchi.

I don\'t think its really that lopsided... i\'d consider it fairly even but would hate to give up Thornton or Malkin so I don\'t know which side of the trade i\'d prefer to be on

__________________
13 team points only keeper
2C, 2LW, 2RW, 3D and 1G plus 5 player bench
Keep 6 plus entire farm

C: Lecavalier, Ribeiro
LW: Elias, Booth
RW: Kessel, Pominville
D: Karlsson, Phaneuf, Bouwmeester
G: Pavelic

Bench: Malkin, Savard, Langenbrunner, Markov, Brouwer
Farm: Frolik, Gagner, Little, Turris, B. Connolly, Kuznetsov, Ekman-Larson

I have to sit on the fence in the middle here, but lean towards the Thornton/Fleury side

Thornton and Malkin are a wash, granted Malkin gets a few more years

Lehtonen may be as good as Fleury but the team situation makes a huge difference. This difference is critical. Fleury will put up comparable SV% or GAA as Lehtonen but will be massive in the wins category for the next few years.

You may get another year out of Recchi, or you may not given some of the additions in Pitts. Demitra - it\'s a downhill slope. Cheechoo is likely to have a better year this year and is on the upside rather than downside.

Ranger is probably equivalent to anyone on the waiver right now so he\'s irrelevant

In the end it\'s the Lehtonen Fleury difference that makes the Fleury side better

__________________
12 team keeper
12F, 6D, 2G, 5 bench (protect 15)

F&D: 1pt for: G,A,PPG,SHG,OTG,GWG,+/-(for the D only), .25PIM
G: 3W, 1OT, -1GA, .1SV, 3SO

F: Ovechkin, Hossa, Stastny, Backstrom, Datsyuk, JCarter, Downie, Parenteau, Ott, Neil, Ribeiro, Hejduk, Clarkson, Dorsett, McDonald

D: Suter, Letang, Doughty, Karlsson, Lidstrom, Kulikov, Pronger, Quincey

G: Price, Rinne

Thanks I decline the trade. We play a head to head matches. With Catagories, who ever has the most \&quot;ie\' goals wins a point for the week, There is 11 catagories in our match ups. I think the tradewas one side and thought this would help my decision. Thanks

__________________
+/-.gls,assit,Dgls,Dassit,GWG,PPG,PIM,SV%,GAA,Wins
8FD,4D,2G 22 players total,Salary Cap of 58million
Shannon ,Malkin,Connolly,Peverley,Vermette,Frolov,Moulson,
Stewart, Tanguay,Downie,Umberger,
Foster, M Green, Jov,Kaberle,Gilroy,Letang,
Biron, Huet,Conklin, ,Theodore