Pick a group for a points only keeper

1) Carlson, Voracek, 1st in 2014 (likely 7th overall)
2) Granlund, 1st 2013 (likely 7th overall), 2nd 2014 (likely 15th overall)
3) Oshie, Kadri, 1st 2013 (likely 2nd overall)

Please give me some guidance on this one, #3 is intriguing to me because I would land someone like McKinnon or Drouin

Thanks