Ok guys,

Who wins this trade ?

Derek Stepan
Brad Richards
Sergei Gonchar

For

Ryan Getzlaf
Tyler Myers
Brandon Saad

__________________
Keeper league with salary cap,16 GM's,max 38 players/team,UFA/RFA system,contracts.
Cats:fwd(1pt=1pt)top 6 count -Malkin/Neal/Eberle/RNH/Gagner/Getzlaf/B.Ryan/Lecavalier
D(G=2,A=1.5)top 4 count- Letang/OEL/J.Schultz(Edm)/Wiercioch/Vatanen/Sproul
goalies(save%,W,SO)top 2 count-Fleury/Dubnyk/Lehner
plus 4 other cats(top powerfwd(C.Perry),setupman(St-Louis),sniper(Stamkos)rookie(Strome,Toffoli,Terava inen,Saad,Jaskin,Ritchie)

Playoffs Champion 2009 and 2010, Reg.season Champion 2011-12,2012-13

Getz side for me. Gonchar is on the downside of his career. Stepan is good, but bound to 2nd line duties. Myers like Chara, will get better with age and experience. Saad is a solid prospect. I fully suspect Getz will rebound in the points department, he's too good not to.

__________________



Points only keeper League, weekly head to head, 2RW, 2LW, 2C, 4D, 1 G , (goalies 2pts for W +3 for SO)



LW: Gaborik, Landeskog, Burrows

C: Seguin, Skinner, Berglund, Nyquist, Lombardi

RW: Eberle, Oshie, Doan, Silfverberg

D: Doughty, Carlson, Ekman-Larsson, Carle

G: Price , Schneider, Nabokov

i agree, but i am not as high on myers.... babchuck or any other big D.

__________________
10 team Dyn
tavares rnh statsny
AO benn
kessel malkin
ryan purcell
green letang enstrom kulkov OEL ellis
lundy ward varly bernier lehrner
burmistrov hodgson michalek, ryan oreilly, turris okposo

16 team h2h
Spezza, Tavares
Vanek,doan
malkin, eberle
Doughty Letang, karlsson, weber
hall
green enstrom downie palmeiri kassain bogo
lundy price pavelec

weiters fielder kipnis wright hanley braun upton upton maybin victorino goldschmidt
kershaw, startsburg, greinke, bumgarner, price, neise, bret anderson
valverde, hanrahan, aceves, reed, guerra, storen

With a full keeper, I'm going with the Getz side. Good future for them all. Gonchar is on the decline, and while Stepan is up-and-coming, he's stuck on 2nd line duties.
Are you in win now mode? If yes, i might go with the Stepan side as you'd still get solid value from Gonchar for the next year or two.

__________________
14 Team, 10-keeper, Second Year Keeper League - Roto
G, A, +/-, PIM, PPP, SHP, GWG, SOG, Hits, Blks, FW, W, GAA, SV%, SHO
2 C, 4 W, 2 F, 5 D, 2 Util, 2 Goalies, 2 IR, 5 Bench

C: Toews, Stepan
W: Lucic, Pacioretty, E. Kane, Briere
F: St. Louis, Landeskog
D: Pietrangelo, Faulk, Beauchemin, Barrie, Zanon
Util: Hodgson, B. Schenn
Bench: Dubinsky, Grossman, M. Foligno
G: Lundqvist, Varlamov
Bench: Hiller, Markstrom
IR Burns, Hanzal

Defending Champion

Thanks guys , I will keep the Getz side . I 'm going for it this year and the Nyr guys would help in playoffs but the price is too high .

__________________
Keeper league with salary cap,16 GM's,max 38 players/team,UFA/RFA system,contracts.
Cats:fwd(1pt=1pt)top 6 count -Malkin/Neal/Eberle/RNH/Gagner/Getzlaf/B.Ryan/Lecavalier
D(G=2,A=1.5)top 4 count- Letang/OEL/J.Schultz(Edm)/Wiercioch/Vatanen/Sproul
goalies(save%,W,SO)top 2 count-Fleury/Dubnyk/Lehner
plus 4 other cats(top powerfwd(C.Perry),setupman(St-Louis),sniper(Stamkos)rookie(Strome,Toffoli,Terava inen,Saad,Jaskin,Ritchie)

Playoffs Champion 2009 and 2010, Reg.season Champion 2011-12,2012-13