Whos the better keeper and why? Both came with the hype tag but are in different situations.....

Assuming you mean Jesus and not Miguel, the offensive upside has to go to Montero, but one would think hitting half his games in Safeco he'll never truly become the offensive whiz that most expect.

Park advantage would definitely go to Camden Yards, and while Wieters is no slouch in his own regards, he doesn't look like he's as capable of carrying a high AVG as Montero will.

__________________

(MoneyBall) 14-TM / H2H / Daily start keeper
R-HR-RBI-SB-OBP-SLG/W-SV-K-ERA-WHIP-K/9

IF - McCann / Goldschmidt / Hill / Bonifacio / Escobar / Morneau / A-Rod (DL)
OF - Trout / C. Gonzalez / Stubbs / T. Frazier
SP - Strasburg / Grienke / Wilson / G. Gonzalez / Shields / J. Johnson
RP - Clippard / Frieri / Robertson

(HKYLiiga) 10-TM / H2H / Daily start keeper
G-A-PTS-PIM-PPP-SOG-W-GAA-SV%-SHO

C - Tavares (K)
RW - Perry (K)
LW - Ovechkin (K)
D - Letang (K)
G - Price (K)

Agree. Think he pretty much covers it. Pretty close though.

__________________
Roto 5x5 - 1 Yr - 23 active spots (14 hitters, any 9 pitchers) - 5 bench

C - M.Montero, Gattis; 1B - Pujols; 2B - Altuve; SS - A.Escobar; 3B - A.Ramirez; CI: Frazier; MI: Walker; OF: Holliday, Cruz, de Aza, Markakis, Span; UT: ; Joyce P - Cain, Miller, Ogando, Milone, Cashner, Tepesch, Romo, Betancourt; Bench - Tejada, Griffin, Cueto (DL), Greinke (DL), Stanton (DL).

The reason I ask is for this offer

12 team roto scoring keeper league (we keep 16) I am currently 7th so looking to next year.

R, RBI, HR, SB, AVG
K, W, SV, ERA, WHIP

I get: Montero, Bruce, Clippard

I give: Wieters, J.Upton, Ackley

My team:

C: Wieters
1B: A. Gonzalez
2B: Pedroia
SS: Scutaro (Tulo DL)
3B: Longoria
OF: J. Upton, Braun, Pence
DH: Freeman
Bn: Stubbs, Ichiro

SP: Moore, Grienke, Felix, Hellickson, Parker, Skaggs, Anderson
RP: Wilhelmsen,

Wieters still hasnt reached his potential....id rather Wieters