If you need assists/ +/- / PIM then to me Shattenkirk/Downie is the side I'd take. Downie will help you destroy one of your five skater categories alone and Shattenkirk IMO is a great option if you're looking for assists and +/-. I'm fairly confident that Shattenkirk will be a + player by the end of the year.
My two cents.
Goalies: If I'm pickin em you best be sittin em!