I'd take trade #2 if for no other reason than your defense appears that it can use a keeper upgrade. Hello Big Buff! Great D keeper to have -- even in a league without SOGs -- given that it's a goal heavy format. And then to get Loui too....

And depending on how things typically play out in your league, you might even then be able to trade a player or two later who fall out of your top 7 and you would otherwise have to drop for a pick or picks (not 1st round in all likelihood, but you'd essentially be moving back in the draft with 84 keepers already off the board to get two very nice players, one of whom is at a position of need IMO). Good deal!

__________________
14 Team H2H Dynasty League (14 keepers, 21-man roster, no farm)
G, A, PPP, SOG, BS, +/-, GAA, W, SV%

C: Giroux/B.Richards/Ennis/Cullen/Grigorenko
W: Ovechkin/Neal/Nash/Skinner/Eriksson/Silfverberg/Samuelsson(IR)
D: Doughty/Boyle/Faulk/Seabrook/Martin(IR)/Seidenberg/Brodin
G: Fleury/Markstrom/Lehner/Khudobin