It's easily Fleischmann for me. The point production is simply better and he carries less of an injury risk.
14 Team, One-Year League, Weekly Line-ups
Start 3C, 6W, 3D, 1UTIL (3 Bench)
C - Benn (W), Kopitar, C. Wilson (W), Granlund
W - Kessel, St. Louis, Wheeler, Voracek, Fleischmann, Kostitsyn, PMB
D - J. Johnson, Enstrom, Wisniewski, Visnovsky, Franson
IR - Atkinson