Points-only keeper pool with salary cap (dynasty, keep all)

Who would you rather have on defense? I'm not in a win now mode and Brodin has 2 more entry-level contract years than Smith.

Which one is in the best position to produce good offensive numbers?

Thanks in advance!

__________________
10-team Keeper pool, points only (dynasty)
12 forwards, 3 dmen, 2 goalies
Salary cap (player salaries): 70.2M / 11.5M space
Skaters: G=1, A=1, Goalies: W=2, OTL=1, SO=3

F: B. Ryan, P. Kessel, J. Benn, E. Staal, P. Kane, J. Tlusty, J. Silfverberg, J. McGinn, C. Wilson, J. Thornton, E. Kane, K. Turris

D: J. Faulk, V. Hedman, M. Streit

G: H. Lundqvist, M. Smith