Theodore is an average starter, and Harding is an above-average backup. Due to age, I'd say that neither of them are going to get much better, it's a tough call which comes down to how many starts you need.
If you need a few wins and a high SV% here and there, then go with Harding, otherwise it's Theodore.
16 team H2H (We keep everyone)
Positions - 2C, 2LW, 2RW, 4D, 2G, 1Util, 11 Bench, No Farm (We just keep prospects on the bench)
G ,A, +/-, PIM, PPP, SOG, Hits
Wins, Saves, SV%, GAA, SO
Year 1 = 2/16
Year 2 = 13/16
Last year = 4/16
C-Crosby, Lecavalier, Ott (LW), Schwartz, Matthias, Toffoli, Leino (LW)
L-Michalek (RW), Pacrioretty, Hagelin
R- Gallagher, Neil, Read,
D- Markov, Rielly, Wisniewski, Hamilton, Fraser, Dumba, Beauchemin, Trouba, Barrie
G-Fleury, Bryzgalov, Ward, S.Mason, Enroth,