If you are rebuilding, I think Bernier is one piece you build around. Bernier becomes a FA after this season and I sense this might bring the situation to resolution. Dubnyk seems like a guy I would grab on the cheap, but not sure I would want to build my goalie corps around.
This is sort of a moot point since I would not recommend making this deal, but I think Ehrhoff has a higher upside than Erixon. Erixon is very solid in his own end and though he has some offensive skills may become more of a two-way or defensive guy than outright offensive d-man. Especially with guys like Moore, Murray, Savard, and others in CLB. In terms of upside I like Ehrhoff, but he does not exactly fit into a rebuilding plan.
With the number of goalies in play in your league, I have to think that a GM in the running for top dawg would be interested in Theodore, should one of his goalies go down to injury. At that point, I think you could fetch a decent pick straight up for Theodore.
I would pass on this trade.
Dyn Points (14 tms) 12F, 6D, 2G, 8B; unl farm; Scoring: G(1) A(1) Shootout G(1) PIM(.1) +/-(.2) SOG(.05) W(2) SO(3)
Dyn H2H Points (16 tm) - 6F 4D 1G 7B farm 10 (50 gms) Scoring SOG(.3) +/-(1) Hit (.2) GWG(1) PIM(.5) W(10) S(.2) GA (-1) SO (5) F: G(5), A(3), PPG(3), PPA(2) SHG(3) SHA(2) D: G(7) A(5) PPG(3) PPA(3) SHG(3) SHA(2)