Originally Posted by The Wrong Marine
He changed the deal to:
Sharp, Goligoski and Kaberle for my Zajac and OEL
I think Goli and OEL are close fantasy wise and Sharp is a pretty good upgrade over Zajac.
Am I crazy to not accept this or am I overvaluing OEL that much?
I wonder how much OEL will be limited as long as Yandle is still there. Being points only (pretty much) I would think Goligoski is a good replacement. I could even see Goligoski outpoint OEL in the short term. Long-term who knows, but Goligoski is the #1 D in Dallas so if he's a consistent 40+ producer then I wouldn't complain. Sharp over Zajac is a solid upgrade as well.
Personally, I would tell him to remove Kaberle as you'd have to drop someone unnecessarily and just make it: Sharp/Goligoski for Zajac/OEL. But you know how much you like OEL so up to you - just trying to give an unbiased opinion.