I've been sending offers, and I received 2 counter-offers from one manager today. I wanted to get some thoughts on the offers from you guys.

Offer 1:

I give:
Staal
Pavelski
Elliott

I get:
Pominville
Cole
Moulson


Offer 2:

I give:
Pavelski
Wheeler
Edler
Elliott

I get:
Pominville
Ian White
Moulson
Stafford


While I think Moulson is the best player in either deal (IMO), I'm not really a fan of Cole or White, and don't really like having 2 guys from the same team at a given position.

Thoughts on either trade guys?