I think Spurgeon's a better choice. He was mildly productive last year with almost nothing to work with, and he had the team's trust in pretty much every situation, so he should be amply rewarded this year. Plus, he was just a -4 as the defacto #1/#2 guy for half the season on the worst offensive team in the NHL.

__________________
18 team league, keep 12 plus *4 1st/2nd year players (16 total)
Points Only (w/ NHL salaries), start 8F/4D/1G
Note: Defencemen receive 1 point per 45 mins of ice time.

Forwards:
Nash, Vanek, Couture, Berglund, Wheeler, Perron, P. Kane, *Baertschi, Semin, *Nyquist, *Atkinson, Tanguay, Cervenka

Defense:
Ehrhoff, Leddy, Voynov, *Orlov, Timonen, Postma, Brodin, Donovan

Goalie:
Halak, Dubnyk, Neuvirth