Some great comments here guys! These are the sorts of informed discussions I log in here hoping to find.
I really have very little more to add other than to throw some weight behind Girgensons. I see a surefire NHLer in him and that's HUGE in my books, so if you're not just chasing the big upsides and are satisfied with a guy who might give you 40-50 sooner than later he's my choice off the whole list.
Guys like Grimaldi don't interest me in the least and I'd look to cash in on any hype there may be surrounding him. Sure he's talented but how many tiny talented players have wasted away in the AHL through the years. Dobbs has a soft spot for these guys so take his views with a grain of salt.