I ended up taking Scheifele. I do have the option of getting Kreider later on, but its so close I went with the one with a much clearer path. I am pretty certain I will be able to acquire Kreider again as the person who took him in my league does not have an affinity for prospects.
10 Team Keeper League - Cap + 10 Million - 8 Keepers + Rookies
Scoring(Points) - +/- - 1, A - 2.5, G - 3, Hits - 0.5, PIM - 0.5, PPG - 0.5,GWG/SH - 1, GAA - 0.5, SO - 1.5, SPCT - 1, W - 2.5
11 Active F - 5 Active D - 2 Active G - 4 Bench - 2 IR
F - Couture, Hodgson, Staal, Pacioretty, van Riemsdyk, Duchene, E. Kane, Tarasenko, Voracek, Parenteau, Kesler, Bennett, Simmonds, O' Reilly
D - Ekman-Larsson, Doughty, Kronwall, Shattenkirk, Subban
G - Ward(IR), Rask, Holtby
Farm (Yrs left) -Johansen(1), Galchenyuk (2), Scheifele(2)