I'd like to keep Boyle, but in a 13 Team League, I would rather have a second goalie.
Of the goalies you have I like Elliott the least.
Comes down to Pavelec vs. Anderson. Anderson I think holds a greater single season potential, but I feel it comes at more risk as he has Bishop behind him with Lehner in the minors primed and ready, with said options behind him all it will take is a minor slip, on top of that his days as number one probably won't be for much longer. Pavelec on the other hand probably doesn't have the same potential to be as good as Anderson for this season, but comes at less of a risk, and if the Jets hope to make the playoffs Pavelec is going to see a lot of action, on top of that he's a much more appealing option moving forward. I'd go towards Pavelec.