Your team is average at best. Your defense and goaltending should be fine, but you lack the raw fire power up front.
Although your format favours guys like Neal, there's no way in hell I'd take him 5th overall in any imaginable format... there's just too much downside risk in my opinion.
Let's see... Stamkos/Crosby/Malkin/Ovie/Giroux/Tavares/Lundqvist all guys I'd easily take ahead of Neal. I think Neal is being way overvalued by most poolers right now.