Well, well, well...
It seems some of you are warming up to this deal. Lets think about this for a second, d'Arnaud and Syndergaard are not a sure thing, they haven't proven anything at the big league level yet. John Buck is a backup catcher, then the Jays got a solid young catcher in Josh Thole. On top of all that, AA is making sure he can sign Dickey to a contract extension in order to complete the trade. That was a fantastic idea and I think Dickey will definitely agree to an extension in the next few days.
So, Toronto got a Cy Young winner and a solid catcher that is in the big leagues. New York got two could be stars, but who knows? Prospects take so long to develop and the Jays have a great group of scouts that can find guys in the draft.