With the information known, I would reply with a simple "No thanks" and that would be it. I doubt I would counter.

However, some clarification on your league settings would be helpful though. You say 'H2H points based' - what are the point values? The fact that there are 14 skater categories to 4 goalie ones isn't as relevant since it's the total number of points per week against your opponent. This would help gauge the relative value of players vs goalies in your setup. It may not affect this offer much, but would help with future questions. You should also clarify how many you start in each position.

__________________
All I've got...all I've got is insane!