I've gotta say... I'm kind of surprised by the overwhelming response for AP here. You guys make it sound like a no-brainer or something.

It's definitely close, and sure Weber has only cleared 50 once - but so has AP.

In the last two seasons, Weber has scored 48 and 49 points. That's pretty damn good in my books... I'll take that kind of consistency over gambling on where AP will land after one really good season. If AP delivers another 50+ season then I may have a change of heart, but I know what I'll get with Weber.