I realize this is an old post, and for the most part the information within is good.
1. Don't chase SHP
2. SHP is better suited to H2H rather than roto
I won a pool a few years ago thanks to Marian Hossa (Thrashers), who played all situations (mainly due to depth issues) and was a stud in all H2H categories. You need to identify these types of situations.
If you missed out in the draft, then it's time to swap one of your star players with one that gets PK minutes.
If it's a daily start league, and you've got a big bench - you could consider a PK spe******t as long as he doesn't have schedule conflicts with your keepers. Central and Pacific divisions usually have an offset schedule (playing more Tues/Thurs/Sun games).
12 team H2H Keeper (weekly)
(12-man active roster: 2C/2RW/2LW/4D/2G/6BN)
(G,A,+/-,PIM,SHP,SOG / W,GAA,SV%,SO)
Hard Luck Hosers (1st year expansion)
C: Kopitar, Carter
RW: Backes, Doan
LW: Benn, Couture
D: Subban, Goligoski, Doughty, Ekman-Larsson
G: Niemi, Bobrovsky
BN: Wheeler, Yakupov, van Reimsdyk, Plekanec, Carlson, Ward[IR]
keepers in bold