I read the criteria quite thoroughly, thank you, and am beyond pleased that Price/Miller advanced beyond guys like Only-Good-For-Wins-Fleury and I-owe-my-stats-to-Tippet-Bryzgalov.
In a keeper, I take Price. In a one-year, Miller is the easy choice for me. So Miller.
Works out pretty well IMO... in a one-year, with above criteria, I'd probably go:
As my top 5. Add saves (which aren't a factor in this set up) and Ward bumps up a slot.
Price and Rask would probably be #6 and 7.