Originally Posted by cdubb
Thanks GM Gates With the same team I can trade for Chara but keep Buff.
I trade Sharp, Suter, Yandle, Krejci
His Chara, Bergeron, Hamhuis
I know I give up a lot of talent, but I get a FOW leader in Bergeron, and Chara is a stud as you said. They all have good +/- ratings. I could pick up a d prospect like Dumna, Morrow, etc.
I don't like the inclusion of Sharp in this deal.
While I could deal with Suter/Yandle for Chara/Hamhuis and a Krejci/Bergeron switch, adding Sharp throws the balance of the trade out of your favour. You would also be losing overall "trade value" in terms of what you could net from your mentioned players in other potential deals.
That said, I am a big fan of Sharp. He is a roto stud and obviously the best forward in this deal. I'd look to see if another one of your pieces could seal the deal such as Roy, Zajac, Vanek or Eriksson. Even then though, I'd like to see something coming your way. I know you mentioned Dumba or Morrow, but I'd focus on a "win now" piece.