For the fourth consecutive season I had the privilege of competing in the annual Dobber Hockey’s Expert League, which contains essentially the “brain trust” of the DobberHockey plus the two winners of the Pro League (Lord of the Rinks and The Comish) from the season before.

During my three-year stint in the league, I had finished third (2008), eighth (2009) and second (2010) last year, so there was really only one place left for me to claim. Last year’s heart-breaking loss was the one that hurt the most, as the winner (FrozenPool) nipped me on the final weekend of the season. I still condemn you for that one Jason… This week’s column will break down the road to success and hopefully give you an insight into what went down in the DobberHockey Expert league this season and eventually leading to yours truly winning the championship.


League Settings

15-teams: Dry Island Holdout (Tim Lucarelli), Lord of the Rinks (Peter Hadley), Hockey Knight (hockeyknight.com), HR’s Look Ahead (Dave Poleck), FrozenPool (Jason Arbuthnot), Angus Unleashed (Angus), Messier4Life (Anthony Lancione), The Dean's list (Brendan Ross), Thunder Bay Moose (Marty Kwiaton), GMG Market Buzz (Gates Imbeau), The Comish (Russ Miller), Legion of Dobber (Dobber), Cage Match (Steve Laidlaw), Nation of Domination (Brian Kom) and Maaaasquito Bites (myself).

Yahoo! ROTO scoring (G, A, +/-, PIM, PPP, SOG, W, GAA and SV), FAAB, Weekly lineup changes and snake drafting.

Positions 4 C, 4 RW, 4 LW, 6 D, 2 G, 5 bench and 2 IR.


Background Info.

Most of the names in the league you’ll probably recognize. Lord of the Rinks was the dark horse, as he’s the one that has snuck up through the ranks winning the DobberHockey Entry League in 2009-10, and then winning the DobberHockey Pro League in 2010-11, earning a chance to play against the “experts” this season.


I was also not picked by as a potential winner by any of the noteworthy forum members in the Dobber Expert League thread. Well known forum members such as Pengwin, Renegade and Joos all went with Gates, Lucarelli, Dobber, Miller and Arbuthnot instead.


Initial Draft

I was drafting from position 11, which I was 50/50 about. I was upset that I missed out on one the first four picks, but I was happy that I at least ended up in the middle. In these types of drafts which included many experts, it’s very hard to plan 30 picks ahead of time, especially if you’re on the edge of the snake draft, so snagging the 11th pick allowed me to determine the trend of each round, making my life a lot easier throughout the draft.


The entire recap of the draft can be found here and a breakdown of each of my picks can be found here.


Looking back at it retrospectively, Patrik Elias, Daniel Alfredsson, Joffrey Lupul and Gabriel Landeskog in rounds 10, 11, 16 and 18 proved to be the difference makers for me. Overall I didn’t have very many “do-overs”, James Wisniewski, Devin Setoguchi, Milan Hejduk and Brad Boyes in rounds nine, 12, 14 and 15 were probably the biggest ones, but they weren’t too detrimental at the end of the day.


After my initial draft I finished with:

C- Crosby, Thornton, Toews, Langkow, Hanzal

LW- Hall, Elias, Lupul, Landeskog, Sturm

RW- Alfredsson, Setoguchi, Hedjuk, Boyes, Dorsett

D- Lidstrom, Edler, Wisniewski, Gonchar, Carkner, Jovanovski, Larsson

G- Brodeur, Smith, Emery


For a 15-teamer with that many positions, I was quite pleased with it. I didn’t think it was a championship team right from the get-go, but still felt quite positive. The primary areas that I needed to address were the goalies and a bit more depth in the wings.


Season Breakdown

At the start of the season everything was just settling down, so it wasn’t surprising not to see a lot of moves being made. I ended up snagging Matt Niskanen and Daniel Winnik primarily because of their SOG totals (one of the major areas for identifying player trends) and traded out Sturm (after his horrible start and then getting traded to FLA).


On October 31, I was tied for fourth place (84.5 points) as Lord of the Rinks stormed out of the gates with 105 points overall, leaving me over 20 points behind the leader (mostly because of struggling goalie stats 3.5 in WIN, 6 in GAA and 5 in SV), so something needed to be addressed here.


The biggest move of the season was the trade that took place on Halloween day. I took full advantage of the news of Crosby being cleared for contact, so I tossed a few lines out there. One of the things with drafting Crosby was that I knew that I was either going to 1) live and die with him or 2) move him in a deal that would boost the rest of my team. I decided on the latter, which saw me land Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Dan Boyle and Kari Lehtonen from HR’s Look Ahead (Polek) for Crosby, Gonchar and Emery. That enabled me to upgrade two key positions, cementing my goalie starts with Brodeur, Smith and Lehtonen, while taking a slight downgrade from Crosby to RNH (11 points in 11 games at the time).


Much of the same for November, as I just made three moves. Ended up snagging Zac Rinaldo (73 PIM and 10 SOG in the first 14 contests), Slava Voynov (after he was recalled from the minors in mid-November) and Kurtis Foster (PP TOI that he was receiving in Anaheim) while dropping Langkow, Jovanovski and Winnik. At the end of November, I ended up making up the difference and now was sitting pretty in second place (93.5 points) and trailing the leader Dry Island Holdout (Tim Lucarelli) by just six points.


Once again a pretty quiet December as I only ended up making two roster moves with the additions of Kyle Palmieri (recalled from the minors to audition on the top line with Ryan Getzlaf and Corey Perry) and Carl Hagelin (SOG being the major determining factor 16 in eight contests) while returning Foster back to the waiver wire. At the end of December, I dropped back down to fourth (84.5 points), with Messier4Life (Lancione) now claiming the top position with 99 points.


January was when the trade talks really started to pick up as five of the 11 trades this season took place in the first month of the New Year.


After doing a bit of research for Dobber’s Midseason Guide and succumbing to my biases I sent out a pretty stupid boneheaded offer (at the time) of Alfredsson (31 points in 35 games) for Sam Gagner (0.76 point-per-game numbers after the ASB) to Dry Island Holdout (Lucarelli) and obviously he accepted with pleasure. I luckily ended up escaping out of that one relatively unscathed (Alfy 28 points and 98 SOG in 40 games, Gagner 28 points and 85 SOG in 42 games as the post-trade numbers).


A week later I was involved in two more blockbuster trades. First I moved Jonathan Toews (44 points in 45 games) to Messier4Life (Lancione) for Vinny Lecavalier (32 points in 43 games) and Chris Kunitz (29 points in 43). I mostly used splits stats as my main determinant, as Toews was a very strong player on the road, but was average at home and Chicago had a few more home games remaining on the rest of the schedule.


The second part of the blockbusters saw me move Hall (30 in 35), Lupul (47 in 44) and Lidstrom (24 in 44) to Thunder Bay Moose (Kwiaton) for St. Louis (35 in 38), Pavelski (31 in 41) and Bogosian (19 in 42). Dobber pretty much predicted it with a crystal ball in his summary of the trade in his ramblings. Once again, I was mostly playing the splits with this one. I wanted the combo of Lecavalier and St. Louis for the second half (because of the remaining home/away splits), plus I already had the Thornton/Boyle combo, so I wanted to add another piece to that puzzle.


Funny thing about the trades is how every player I traded away went down with a significant injury of some sort soon afterwards. Toews, Hall, Lupul and Lidstrom all missed noteworthy time, so I guess I caught a few breaks on that one.


A final minor trade saw me move underachiever, Setoguchi (17 points in 34 contests), to Angus for another, Patric Hornqvist (22 points in 45 contests). Looking back at it retrospectively, saw me slightly win that one, as Seto finished with a line of 19 points and 86 SOG in 34 contests compared to Horny’s 22 points 105 SOG in 29 games post-trade.


In terms of moves, January was the busiest month for me as I snagged Nazem Kadri, Erik Condra, Trevor Daley, Carl Gunnarsson, Ryan Reaves, Wojtek Wolski, Tom Wandell, David Savard, T.J. Galiardi and Yannick Weber while letting go of Palmieri, Dorsett, Carkner, Larsson, Boyes, Hagelin and Niskanen. Most of those moves were “hot” pickups for the weeks, so there wasn’t anything really significant there.


After a pretty active January, I managed to climb back up to 91.5 points and cut down the margin between the leader, Lord of the Rinks (Peter), and me down to 6.5 points.


February was once again fairly quiet on the moves front, but I did end up pulling off a “trade that helped put me over the edge”. I ended up moving Kunitz, Gunnarson, RNH, Smith and Lehtonen in a “win-win” trade with The Dean’s List (Ross) for Alex Tanguay, Matt Carle, Derick Brassard and Henrik Lundqvist. I broke down the trade in my Anatomy of Trading column back in February.


Numbers post-trade:

































I may have lost out on the goalie stats in the end, but with Brodeur, Smith and Lehtonen at the time I was just spending too much time trying to decide which of the three to start and causing me a fair share of headaches. With Lundy and Brodeur, my goalie stats were taken care of and I was essentially worry-free. What also pushed me over the edge were my initial thoughts of Tanguay and Brassard coming into fruition. Both gambles ended up in my favour and ultimately led to the championship for me.


In terms of the moves front, I ended up adding Kyle Broziak (Mikko Koivu injury), Roman Josi (was thinking Ryan Suter being traded at deadline) and Matt Taormina (lack of NJ PP QB) while letting go Wandell and Weber.


February was the month that I finally pulled ahead of the pack. I finished off the month with 104 points along with a miniscule 3.5 point lead over Lord of the Rinks.


With the trade deadline passing, and heading into the final month of the fantasy season, there wasn’t a lot that could be done. It’s pretty much taking a “sit and wait” approach. A few minor ww moves were made, I ended up picking up Brett Clark (TB PP QB), Jamie McGinn (hot-streak after the trade deadline), David Moss (SOG), Mark Letestu (garnering tons of TOI after the roster clean up), Johnny Oduya, Brandon Bollig (PIM) and Chad LaRose, while letting Taormina, Galiardi, Ganger, Hanzal, Josi, Wolski and Wisniewski go.


On March 30th, Lord of the Rinks held a slim 105.5 to 104.5 lead against me, with essentially a week to go. With big days on Tuesday and Thursday last week, I managed to pull ahead with an unsuspecting nine-point lead after all of Thursday’s nights matches and I was beginning to think that I was in the clear. I held the front on Saturday night and ending up finishing the season with a 10-point win and the DobberHockey Expert League crown.


Here are the final standings of the league.






Near Hits or Misses

  • At the fantasy trade deadline I sent an offer of Pavelski and Hornqvist out to Dobber for Jeff Skinner and Teddy Purcell in which he scoffed at in reply.

Stats since the offer:
























I was quite lucky that he knocked that offer back as the difference of seven goals and 44 SOG would have cost me three points.

  • Also with GMGates and Comish on other either side of me of the draft, I knew that I was going to get sniped fairly often.


Commish snagged Ryan Getzlaf the pick before Toews in round 4, which could have made a large difference, (negatively), in the end of season result if I landed Getzlaf instead of Toews.


I had Ryan Suter all queued up and ready to click just to see his name disappear the pick right before my ninth-round Wisniewski pick. If I had him instead, this would have been locked up months ago.


Stephen Weiss and Ian White were also on my radar in the 14th round, but both were taken three and four picks respectively before mine which left me with Hejduk. Landing Weiss or White also would have cemented the title for me much earlier.


Nikolai Khabibulin was also a goalie that had piqued my interest, by the 24th round and about two hours into the draft, he was at the top of my queue and ready to be selected onto my team. Dobber ended up snagging him two picks before me which left me with Emery. Now if you can remember back to the very start of the season, Khabibulin started the season in blazing fashion with a 7-0-2 record along with an unbelievable 0.98 GAA and .964 SP. If I had those stats to start the season that would have certainly made me re-think my goalie strategy and I probably would have hung onto Crosby instead of moving him for Lehtonen when I did, which would have definitely changed the final outcome of the league.


  • After consulting with LOTR, he had a bit of “comedy of errors” during the draft. You can read it here.


“Were I to do things differently I would have most definitely picked 2 goalies with my top 4 picks - (with the #2 overall pick I had I would have selected either Lundvist or Stamkos had I been picking "live") against more competitive players I've always found that building a solid foundation with goaltending in fantasy hockey is the key to a top 3 finish.”


Another “big deal” that occurred during the season was LOTR moving Brian Campbell and Curtis Sanford for Jonas Hiller and Ryan McDonagh in mid-January, but I was lucky enough to counter that move with my Lundy-trade a month later. If I didn’t make that counter, that edge could have easily gone to LOTR instead.


All in all it was a great season all around, most of the “experts” that I follow closely finished near the top of the standings, while a few disappointed (I’m looking at you Angus!), and Jason (you can stay down there forever and ever!). It should be a tight race once again next season.


Questions or comments? As always I’ll discuss them in the section below.


Should you be so inclined, follow me on Twitter.


Write comment
Comments (0)add comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.