Fantasy Impact: Colorado traded rugged winger Chris Stewart, prized young defenseman Kevin Shattenkirk, and a 2nd round draft pick to St. Louis in exchange for former 1st overall pick Erik Johnson, shutdown center Jay McClement, and a conditional 1st round pick. One of the most surprising (and interesting) trades in recent memory.


The Avalanche get: A defenseman with the upside to be dominant at both ends of the ice. Johnson has all the tools necessary to be a franchise defenseman – smarts, size, speed, and a nice blend of offensive and defensive talent. McClement is one of the best defensive centers in the game, and he immediately boosts Colorado’s PK in a big way. Johnson is far and away the key part of this deal, but McClement will be welcomed site to both Brian Elliott and Peter Budaj. The 1st round pick is dependent on one thing – the Blues can defer it to 2012 if it ends up being somewhere in the top 10. This condition may end up working for Colorado, as the 2012 draft is shaping up to be a very strong one.


The Blues get: One of the best young power forwards in the game in Stewart, and a budding offensive star in Shattenkirk. Stewart, like most other Avs, has been struggling for the past month or so. He has the potential to be a 40-goal scorer with an intimidating physical streak. Shattenkirk is a fluid skater who reads the ice very well as a rookie. His upside from an offensive standpoint is just as high as Johnson’s (if not higher).


Fantasy Players Impacted:


Essentially every player on either team is affected by this deal. Every player in the trade will see an immediate boost in value because they will want to prove themselves to their new clubs. Stewart bumps a few forwards down the depth chart in St. Louis. This deal was able to happen for a few reasons. The Blues felt comfortable building around Alex Pietrangelo going forward, and Colorado felt Shattenkirk was expendable because of their immense depth in terms of offensively talented defensemen in the pipeline. Giving up Stewart hurts but Johnson (and a potentially good draft pick) is a pretty nice return.


This deal is a precursor to another move for at least one of these teams. Colorado will probably move John-Michael Liles, and they may try to snag a winger in return. The Blues have a wealth of depth at forward and Stewart only adds to the logjam. I would expect Brad Boyes to be on the move.


St. Louis fans should get excited at the potential for a Shattenkirk-Pietrangelo duo on the power play for the next decade. The Blues now have the luxury of putting a punishing, talented forward on each line with Stewart and David Backes. Few – if any – teams can claim to have two 30+ goal scorers who can fight and hit with regularity. TJ Oshie, Patrik Berglund, Stewart, Backes, Alex Steen, and David Perron is an impressive young core of forwards to build around. Don’t forget the prospects or Andy McDonald, either.


Colorado now has a franchise defenseman to add to a franchise forward (Matt Duchene). Look for Johnson to be revitalized by the move – don’t forget he was picked over Jonathan Toews, Nick Backstrom, and Jordan Staal for a reason. The Avalanche will be getting Tomas Fleischmann back for next season, and potentially Peter Mueller as well.


The trade boils down to two young stars (Stewart and Johnson) that have both been struggling and inconsistent this season. Shattenkirk and the draft picks are also very important pieces, but the deal will be won and loss on the development of Stewart and Johnson.


The real winner from this whole thing could be David Jones.... funny to think about, isn't it?



Fantasy Players this helps, in order:

Erik Johnson
David Jones
Alex Pietrangelo (short and long term)
Patrik Berglund (long term)
Andy McDonald
Vladimir Sobotka
Tyson Barrie/Stefan Elliott (long term)
Ryan Stoa (long term)



Fantasy Players this hurts, in order:

Brad Boyes
Carlo Colaiacovo (when healthy)
Ian Cole (long term)
Kevin Shattenkirk
Alex Steen
TJ Oshie (long term)


Write comment
Comments (8)add comment

lokguin said:

Fleischmann Fleischmann is UFA starting July 1st. There is no guarantee he'll return to play for Colardo.
February 21, 2011
Votes: +0

kevin said:

Stastny Stastny seems to be a glaring omission from this analysis. I would say he is most affected by the departure of Stewart and hurt more overall by the trade than anyone else.
February 20, 2011
Votes: +0

Jeff Angus said:

... Hurts his value on the Blues. I'm not assuming he is going to get traded in my evaluations.

February 19, 2011
Votes: +0

TML said:

Boyes Hey Angus!

I don't think this will hurt Boyes. If Boyes does indeed get traded because of this, it will help him.
February 19, 2011
Votes: +0

AFlyers66 said:

... Great move for Stefan Elliott owners. EJ/Elliott running the COL PP one day soon....sweet. Nice combo of size and speed.
February 19, 2011
Votes: +0

Ry Guy said:

... I figured the same thing; that this deal would help T.J. Oshie short term.

I think it's Oshie who gets helped the most this season, but it's close between him and David Jones
February 19, 2011
Votes: +0

Ry Guy said:

... What pace can we expect from Oshie and David Jones moving forward for the rest of this year?
February 19, 2011
Votes: +0

Killer67 said:

Oshie? This hurts Oshie but helps Berglund? I thought it was Oshie who was the higher regarded player? In this case, would you drop Oshie for Berglund if you could only have 1 Blues Center?
February 19, 2011
Votes: +0
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.