Another simple audit. Points-only, no goalies. Some interesting keeper questions, including the likes of Frolik, Vanek, Gagner, Wolski, and Derek Roy. Thanks to DobberHockey reader Andy for sending this one in.

The League

OPHL

The Team

London Aviators

The Rules

10 Team Keeper League

Points only (Goal = 1, Assists =1)

10 Keepers

Draft each off-season to fill out roster to 20

Must have at least six defenseman at all times during the season

The Roster

His keeper selections:

My keeper selections:

Recent Trades

Outgoing: James van Riemsdyk, Matt Niskanen, Peter Mueller

Incoming: Dion Phaneuf, David Krejci, Michal Frolik

Great trade. Phaneuf is an upgrade on Niskanen. Krejci is a shor-term upgrade on both JVR and Mueller as well.

Outgoing: Dion Phaneuf, Andrei Kostitsyn

Incoming: Wojtek Wolski, Brent Burns

A decent trade. Phaneuf would probably have been a keeper. I like Wolski as a keeper as well. The other two wouldn't make the grade.

Outgoing: Marc Savard, Justin Williams

Incoming: Derek Roy, Sam Gagner

Great trade, again. Williams is done as a productive NHL'er.

Recommendations

1) Keep Wolski over Gagner. I really like Gagner’s long-term upside, but Wolski will out-point him over the next few seasons. I may get some heat for this, but I actually debated keeping Gagner over Vanek. In a points-only league (no differentiation between goals and assists), Vanek’s value drops a bit.

2) Try and upgrade. You have a few good borderline keepers, especially on defense. None of them after Weber interested me that much, but perhaps you can swing a few of them for an upgrade on the back end (landing a potential second keeper defenseman).

Comments (1)

Subscribe to this comment's feed

blake mansbridge said:

	... cant agree that savard for roy is a great trade when gagner is being dropped. Same with the phaneuf trade why trade him when you werent planning on keeping wolski?
	report abuse vote down vote up

July 17, 2010
Votes: +0