Part 1


The second part of a two-part look at some training camp battles with fantasy implications.


The battles on the blueline are, generally speaking, for a No. 6 or 7 spot, with the winners seeing – at best – 30 points this year. We’ll run through them quickly before taking a closer look at the forwards.


Carolina: Bryan Rodney vs. Jamie McBain. With Anton Babchuk gone (KHL), a spot opens up for one of these youngsters.

Anaheim: Luca Sbisa vs. Steve Eminger. The latter has the advantage due to a one-way contract and the fact that the former needs to be in the top five or the team won’t waste his development.

Boston: Andy Wozniewski vs. Johnny Boychuk. The winner will be the No.7 rearguard.

Dallas: Ivan Vishnevsky vs. Jeff Woywitka.  The latter is running out of chances.

Nashville: Cody Franson vs. Jonathan Blum vs. Teemu Laakso. Two spots with three vying.

New Jersey: Cory Murphy vs. Matthew Corrente. Murphy needs to stay healthy and if so he will get some PP time if he wins this battle.

St. Louis: Steve Wagner vs. Alex Pietrangelo vs. Brenden Bell. All three have offensive ability and two of them could make the team.

Tampa Bay: Matt Lashoff vs. Kurtis Foster vs. Matt Smaby vs. Matt Walker. Poolies will only be interested if Lashoff or Foster win this battle.


Onto the forwards – the real fantasy impact.


NY Islanders: Blake Comeau vs. Sean Bergenheim vs. Jeff Tambellini vs. Jesse Joensuu

For Grabs: Winner plays with John Tavares. Two runners up play with Josh Bailey or Doug Weight.

Repercussions: The loser will be in the AHL or press box. For Comeau or Tambellini, that could eventually lead to a career in Europe or something along those lines. The winner could top 55 points, depending on J.T.’s impact.

Inside Track: I like Joensuu with Tavares, although we may not see that until midseason. Tambellini is on the outside looking in.


NY Rangers: Artem Anisimov vs. Brian Boyle

For Grabs: A third-line center spot.

Repercussions: Another year in the AHL for the loser. You can’t have too many of those when you’re in your early 20’s.

Inside Track: Anisimov has proven superior in training camp thus far.


Ottawa: Ryan Shannon vs. Mike Fisher or Shannon vs. Jonathan Cheechoo

For Grabs: Two spots in the top six.

Repercussions: Shannon was out of chances last year, yet he still got one more. He did well with it, but he needs to build on that or he will be a career minor leaguer. Fisher is best suited for the third line so if the Sens try Shannon back and center and it works, then the issue is solved. Cheechoo will be a top six winger for at least the first 20 games. If Shannon can’t get the No.2 center job then he’ll have to wait for Cheechoo to flounder for his next (and probably final) opportunity.

Inside Track: The easy answer is ‘Fisher and Cheechoo’. I have to go with the easy answer, as much as I like what I’ve heard about Shannon these past seven months. Fisher’s recent hat trick only helps him.


Philadelphia: James van Riemsdyk vs. Patrick Maroon

For Grabs: A third-line spot

Repercussions: Nothing serious. Either a 30-point rookie season or a one-year delay before making the show.

Inside Track: As well as Maroon has played, you have to still give the edge to their golden boy JVR.


Phoenix: Petr Prucha vs. Taylor Pyatt vs. Radim Vrbata vs. Kyle Turris vs. Mikkel Boedker

For Grabs: The entire second line

Repercussions: Assuming Matt Lombardi, Peter Mueller and Shane Doan are already in the top six (with Mueller probably right wing or possibly center, depending on how Turris does).

Inside Track: Vrbata and Turris. I think Pyatt will initially get a top six spot, but when he fails to produce (as always happens with him) it will be Boedker.


Pittsburgh: Luca Caputi vs. Eric Tangradi vs. Chris Conner vs. Ryan Bayda vs. Konstantin Pushkarev

For Grabs: Many auditions on a line with either Sidney Crosby or Evgeni Malkin.

Repercussions: Obviously huge.

Inside Track: Ruslan Fedotenko, Chris Kunitz and Bill Guerin will all see time on those lines, so this battle is technically for just one spot. However, if two players proved themselves, coach Dan Bylsma wouldn’t mind. Caputi had the edge after a strong prospect camp, but Tangradi has shown far more once exhibition season started.


Tampa Bay: Steve Downie vs. Martins Karsums vs. Drew Miller vs. Carter Ashton

For Grabs: A spot on a line with Vincent Lecavalier and Alex Tanguay.

Repercussions: Possibly numbers in the 50-point range.

Inside Track: Most people pick Downie for this spot, but I’ve always figured Karsums to be a better fit (and a more disciplined one), with Miller as a long shot. How about ‘D’, none of the above? Ashton was in camp basically for the experience, as team brass certainly didn’t want to rush him. But he has shown excellent poise and maturity and has already seen some game action on the big line. Watch this situation closely.


Toronto: Tyler Bozak vs. Rickard Wallin vs. Jason Allison vs. Nazem Kadri; Viktor Stalberg vs. Christian


For Grabs: Lots going on in Toronto. The No.3 center job and a top six winger job, with lots of candidates.

Repercussions: Either job could see a 45-point player this year.

Inside Track: Bozak and Stalberg are having an excellent camp. So is Kadri, but he would be best served with one more year of junior.


Vancouver: Sergei Shirokov vs. Mason Raymond vs. Mikael Samuelsson

For Grabs: A spot on the Sedin line.

Repercussions: The difference between 30 to 40 points and 45 to 60 points.

Inside Track: It’s Samuelsson’s spot to lose, but so far he might be losing it – to Shirokov, who is having an excellent camp.


Write comment
Comments (8)add comment

aj said:

mat corrente I know mat he's been really working hard in the summer. He's really in good shape, I'm hope he get's his shot. He's a tough kid.

September 22, 2009
Votes: +0

tim crowell said:

Kulikov and Sekera I've got Sekera in a 20 team yahoo rotiserrie. I'm wondering if Kulikov who is available is making the big leap.
September 22, 2009
Votes: +0

paul faure said:

Fisher Ottawa has been trying to put Fisher on the third line for YEARS. They always thought he was the center, but finally they tried him on the wing and he seems to be flying. His recent success only proves that he will fill out our third line. But in reality, Ottawas second and third line will be more a 2a and 2b with equal ice time. This mornings practice lines:
Michalek - Spezza - Alfredsson
Foligno - Shannon - Kovalev
Cheechoo - Regin - Fisher
Ruutu - Neil - Kelly

Phillips - Volchenkov
Kuba - Karlsson
Carkner - Campoli
Picard - Lee

PS. Regin has been great during the preseason and is now looking at PP time. He made the team for SURE. Same goes for Karlsson.
September 21, 2009
Votes: +0

Mark said:

Samuelsson Has anyone heard how he is shaping up in the pre season? There hasn't been much press that I have seen to this point. Shirokov has made lots of news with his play. Sounds like a keeper. I hope he can flourish in Canuck Land.
September 21, 2009
Votes: +0

drury2396 said:

... Dobber, I'm 99.9% sure Anisimov will center the third line and Boyle the fourth. I'd be shocked if either started off the season in Hartford. They've been using Boyle on an energy line with Voros and Brashear, and that has been the most consistent line the past two games. He's taken defensive zone draws and killed penalties - he's looked good, but as a poolie, it's dissapointing. I thought Boyle would amount to a solid second or third liner who would dominate the front of the net on the power-play, but Torts is basically using him as a replacement for Betts who can chip in more offense.
September 20, 2009
Votes: +0

Dobber said:

... They're very happy with Stamkos-Malone-St.Louis from end of last year, and training camp this year. That's pretty much in stone, those three. At least for now. you know how fickle line combos are though
September 20, 2009
Votes: +0

Bob Farls said:

pens Tyler Kennedy will be the other player in the pens top six. The Pens brass has no intention of rushing Caputi or Tangradi and they don't need to. Kennedy will not only make it on Malkin's wing, but he'll score 20 this year. You heard it here first smilies/wink.gif
September 20, 2009
Votes: +0

lanky522 said:

Downie Didn't downie have good chemistry with Stamkos? Why wouldn't they put him there instead? I don't think the top line is good for him either... but i could definitely see him fitting well on the second weith S.S.
September 20, 2009
Votes: +0
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.